Subject: Constructive criticism is great
Author:
Posted on: 2015-11-01 21:02:00 UTC

I do it all the time, pointing out SPaG and continuity errors, and occasional a confusing narration or lack of canon knowledge, in recently published stories, so that the author(s) can correct their mistakes or explain their choices when I wasn’t aware that there is a choice.

It’s a bit different with older missions, where the author isn’t around anymore. You may argue that others still can learn from your concrit, even if the author never sees your comment, and that we should acknowledge that the PPC isn’t infallible. (I actually did this with my very first comment on this board.) But then you should be sure that there really is a mistake.

Thinking that every lack of required capitalization should spawn a mini that should be caught may be excusable, since you apparently weren’t around when this was discussed on the board, and the wiki doesn’t say that there is an unresolved dispute. Implying that you intend to rewrite history and retroactively catch shadow lord feels like you are sporking a PPC mission, and, considering that we only spork the most awful fics, this is a Bad Idea that should be restricted to the Badfic Games. So I’m glad you dropped the idea.

HG

Reply Return to messages