Subject: Oh, absolutely.
Author:
Posted on: 2019-01-11 11:33:00 UTC

If they explicitly link this to the movies - Sir Ian or Orli appearing seem the most likely ways, or Agent Elrond - then contradicting those movies is going to jar quite hard. I can see a partial recasting going very sideways - 'why does Arwen look different when Gandalf looks the same?!' - but also if they do things that would break the plot of the films.

The funniest thing will be if they do something book-accurate which disagrees with Jackson. How about black walls around Minas Tirith? Or accurate distances between various points?

hS

Reply Return to messages