Subject: Sorry for the late reply
Author:
Posted on: 2020-11-17 19:35:41 UTC
I know we don't discriminate based on kinks, however, the kinks aren't the only reason I feel the stories are bad. They were just the expired cherry on the top.
However, you do have a point about the whole author thing, and sorry for that.
I'd like these to be PPC'd, but I didn't do it on the wiki, because A.) I'm talking about an author's work as a whole, not a single fanfic, and B.) Someone sort of implied I was complaining about grossness too much on the Wiki, so I'm trying to cut off.
It's a woman named Hailey, and her user page on the Pit is [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/11186111/Haileykitty69 here]]. I may be biased, since she writes about kinky stuff and despite knowing about the Your Kink is Not My Kink rule, I hate kinks. That said, I believe her work is objectively bad.
Her stories are all blocks of text, and they usually focus on Principal Skinner from The Simpsons, but she calls him by his first name Seymour. A few of them are unlikely crossovers too, so there's that as evidence for them being badfic. One of them has Maggie speak in full sentences.
I'm also pretty sure that Skinner is OOC in these stories; in essence, either he acts like Nelson (the schoolyard bully) or Ralph Wiggum (the scatty kid in Lisa's class).
Doing so would start dipping into "targeting the author" territory, rather than just critiquing stories. And as we very frequently have to say, we do not target authors here.
Regardless of how you feel about various kinks, kinks are very much a part of fandom culture, and kinks alone aren't enough to make a story bad. Remember that the point of missions is to be amused by the badfic, not grossed out by it. Gross content doesn't necessarily make for a fun/funny mission.
—doctorlit isn't interested in The Simpsons enough to bother reading these
I know we don't discriminate based on kinks, however, the kinks aren't the only reason I feel the stories are bad. They were just the expired cherry on the top.
However, you do have a point about the whole author thing, and sorry for that.