Subject: Uh...
Author:
Posted on: 2012-09-10 16:46:00 UTC
What word?
- There's a storm coming by on 2012-09-08 20:56:00 UTC Reply
-
This has to be a parody by
on 2012-09-08 22:36:00 UTC
Reply
As soon as they mention Ginny Weasely "conveniently becoming a lesbian" and yu hear the first Sue's name, it's obvious. No one would blatantly offer Mary Sue cliches up like that if it wasn't a parody.
-
The worrying thing is... by
on 2012-09-10 01:19:00 UTC
Reply
... that the Mary-Sue Hunters are rather disturbingly characterised. I didn't read far (and can't at present), but I got far enough to reach 'I just hate women and I want a job where I can kill them', which... well, a) is disgusting, but more relevantly, b) plays into the idea that anyone who objects to Mary-Sues Just Hates Women. Which isn't true.
hS -
Not to mention... by
on 2012-09-11 01:18:00 UTC
Reply
They appear to be rather easily swayed by the Suefluence. Something isn't right there...
-
It's because... by
on 2012-09-11 05:13:00 UTC
Reply
...they're a bunch of amateurs. If they were the slightest bit professional, the story would have been over by the eighth page.
In fact, it should have ended something like this: "Damn right, cutie pie! This sista was only here on work exp-" *FLAMETHROWER NOISES* -
Ah, good point. by
on 2012-09-11 05:31:00 UTC
Reply
Although the 'SUDDENLY, ROMANCE' between that particular Sue and the misogynistic Sue Hunter might explain why her sudden appearance was enough to bring things to a screeching halt.
I say they're all lost - Sues or bit-characters, every one. -sigh- And they had such promise...I think... -
How about a fic from the eyes of a Sue? by
on 2012-09-11 06:48:00 UTC
Reply
If done correctly, that would be quite interesting. I know there's an unfinished story on that very topic called "Suedom" hanging around on Miss Cam's website but I never got around to reading it.
-
Suedom's slightly different. by
on 2012-09-11 14:34:00 UTC
Reply
It's more a story seen through the eyes of two unwilling Sues... who work quite hard to stop it.
Also one of them gets gangrene. But it is fun. It's by Andy and Saphie, who were quite famous here once.
hS
(PS: I believe it also features the only known appearance of a certain Agent Huinesoron... ~hS) -
That could be pretty fun, actually. by
on 2012-09-11 06:52:00 UTC
Reply
Mind-numbing, of course, but fun.
-
True by
on 2012-09-10 01:55:00 UTC
Reply
I think the authors have a good idea - I certainly found a lot of it very funny - but they don't seem to really grasp what makes a Mary-Sue a Mary-Sue, or a Mary-Sue Hunter a Mary-Sue Hunter. Several of the "Mary-Sues" get a decent enough characterization that I actually sort of start to like them, while the Mary-Sue Hunters are mostly portrayed as men (There is canonically one female Mary-Sue Hunter, and she's an ex-Sue who mainly wants revenge for being bullied at the Mary-Sue Academy) who don't like other people having fun and kill Sues just for the sake of killing Sues. They're not really out to protect Canon, they just... hate Sues. (And they can very easily be won over by Sue seduction. Like, immediately.)
Only one Sue-Hunter (their leader and founder, though) is of the Just Hates Women type, as far as I can tell, but honestly, most of the Sues are better-characterized than the Sue-Hunters.
I can't tell whether the authors are making fun of overly-dramatic Mary-Sues, playing the devil's advocate just for the challenge, or genuinely believe that Mary-Sues are a good (or at least cool and fun) thing. Either way, though, the Mary-Sue Hunters are, for the most part, presented in a really unflattering way. The whole comic is, while funny, sort of uncomfortable after a while, because I keep wondering, is this really how people see Mary-Sues and the people who hate them? -
From further observation... by
on 2012-09-11 09:15:00 UTC
Reply
... eg here, it seems that the author thinks 'Mary-Sue' is a synonym for 'OFC'... or 'fanon version of female canon'. Which is an incredibly broad definition (coming out as 'woman in fanfic'), and the fact that they are (almost) all portrayed as classic Sues says something bad about this author's respect for fanwriters.
Which is ironic, when you think about it.
hS -
Oh my by
on 2012-09-11 16:53:00 UTC
Reply
That's a twist. Hmm...
Maybe the creators aren't fans of fanfiction in general, so they decided to break their own rules to make everyone who does like fanfiction look silly?
My head is starting to hurt. -
Good point. by
on 2012-09-11 05:56:00 UTC
Reply
I agree - after about the third page, I found myself wondering if this is what Mary Sue-haters look like to the rest of the community.
And then I remembered how I used to react to Twilight-bashing - how I used to look at anyone who went about trumpeting their 'anti-Twilight propaganda,' which usually included pointing out the Sue-ishness of the whole thing - and (while I am now able to laugh at what is becoming less and less of a fandom for me), I find the answer to be yes...conditionally.
Since most of my old run-ins with anti-Twihards were on deviantART - and I've discovered that this is the comic's place of origin - I can't help but wonder if maybe some of the characterization for the Mary Sue Hunters comes from the comments, pictures, and forum posts made by deviants (members of the site, not rogue PPCers or anything like that). If you look, a lot of them - though not necessarily a majority - are less "why Sues are unhealthy for canon" and "how to avoid creating a Sue," and more "OH MY GLOD WHY WOULD YOU DO SOMETHING SO STUPID YOU FAIL AT WRITING FOREVER!"
So, maybe the authors have only ever encountered the out-of-control Sue-haters who are fire and brimstone and BLARGH YOU SHOULDN'T BE ALLOWED TO WRITE. Maybe they don't even know the PPC exists, and think that all Sue-haters are psychotic and don't actually base their Sue-hate on anything logical, like canon breaking or character defiling.
Or...maybe it's just meant to be silly all around. Who knows? -
I didn't even get that far by
on 2012-09-10 01:53:00 UTC
Reply
That is rather disturbing. Is the creator trying to create propaganda perhaps?
-
Highly disturbing. by
on 2012-09-11 05:39:00 UTC
Reply
I'm still convinced that someone will write a worse!fic about this comic and re-Sue all the Sues, quite frankly. By around page...30?...it even attempts to water down some of the Sues by portraying Bella Swan as an 'evil' Sue.
Which they all are...
Anyway, ignoring my pro-Twilight inclination (which, I discover, is waning significantly of late), the whole thing looks like an attempt to show people that Sues can be shades of good and bad too - or at the very least, it's an attempt to say that 'At least they don't kill people!'
Which might create character sympathy. Which could lead to fanfiction. Which would make me cry.
(So many 'which'-es...it looks like Halloween!) -
Re: There's a storm coming by
on 2012-09-08 21:46:00 UTC
Reply
Oh yes, it is funny, and many of the "sues" are really actually well devloped.
Still, it seemed relevant. -
I don't understand by
on 2012-09-08 21:44:00 UTC
Reply
Why is this comic a bad thing? It seems like a parody comic.
-
All I have to say is... by
on 2012-09-10 10:45:00 UTC
Reply
Word.
-
I actually find it very funny. by
on 2012-09-08 21:31:00 UTC
Reply
Clearly, whoever is writing this knows what is s/he doing.
-
A parody, maybe? Oh please, please, please... (nm) by
on 2012-09-08 21:44:00 UTC
Reply
-
It is. (nm) by
on 2012-09-08 22:18:00 UTC
Reply
-
Oh, thank all the deities whose names I know! (nm) by
on 2012-09-09 00:23:00 UTC
Reply
-
And cupcakes? (nm) by
on 2012-09-09 00:42:00 UTC
Reply
-
What? by
on 2012-09-09 00:45:00 UTC
Reply
Cupcakes? Why would I thank cupcakes?
-
oh, you know by
on 2012-09-09 01:09:00 UTC
Reply
Why not?
-
I do? by
on 2012-09-09 01:33:00 UTC
Reply
...You are just the worst kind of person...
-
Re: I do? by
on 2012-09-09 01:40:00 UTC
Reply
Beware of the Specs,
He lurks on the boards... -
My mind. It boggles. (nm) by
on 2012-09-09 01:48:00 UTC
Reply
-
This is what happens when Teh Specs boggles minds. by
on 2012-09-09 01:52:00 UTC
Reply
-
Re: This is what happens when Teh Specs boggles minds. by
on 2012-09-09 02:17:00 UTC
Reply
Just to note: that was supposed to be a link to a funny picture, but it wouldn't post the link, and I'm not sure if images are allowed.
So yeah. -
Images are allowed. by
on 2012-09-09 02:20:00 UTC
Reply
And the Board should accept links, too - either simply by pasting the link, or by using HTML-style coding.
hS
(PS: For reference, that's [a href="http://linkhere"]Here's My Link[/a], with instead of [ and ]. hS) -
Re: Images are allowed. by
on 2012-09-09 02:23:00 UTC
Reply
Thankie.
I need to learn the html codes... -
Re: I actually find it very funny. by
on 2012-09-08 21:34:00 UTC
Reply
Indeed.
But it is, at the same time, terrifying.
("And there was much rejoicing!" "Ye-wait, what?") -
What madness is this? by
on 2012-09-08 21:22:00 UTC
Reply
Are we soon to have a slew of badfics wherein canonical Mary Sues are made into even larger Mary Sues? And why have Sues been made the protagonists? Is this an attempt to show the Sues' point-of-view on the whole 'you are a threat to canon that cannot continue' thing?
Or...oh. Oh, Eru. This isn't a sign that Suethors are learning to PPC-proof their characters, is it? Please tell me that's just me being paranoid.
...And why is Venus the patron Sue-goddess? That's just confusing... -
Teh Specs offers you GUIDANCE! by
on 2012-09-08 21:28:00 UTC
Reply
*Wa-SMACK!*
Calm down, Eru d-[WOOHOO!] it!
This will all be fine, we just have to... You know... Be resilient to the onslaught and other dramatic, hero-sounding stuff.
Yeah.
That'll work. -
and just like that, my day is gone. by
on 2012-09-08 21:09:00 UTC
Reply
Uh oh.
I don't have boots with long enough straps to pull up for this sh-[WOOHOO!]tstorm.