As much as I agree that Arwen shouldn't be thought of as a weak character and devotion and loyalty in women aren't weak traits (I'm a sucker for samurai-like loyalty regardless of gender; there's a reason I write Momoka the way she is), that they glorify being unable to move on from male objects of affection is a bit disturbing and once again shows lack of self-awareness – the same Smauging article praises Éowyn, who successfully moves on from her first love to marry someone else.

...the 'He's a gentleman' part had me wheezing. xD I always say hey, hate Twilight, but hate it for the right reasons - not because it did something weird with vampire mythology or because it's a sappy teen romance that young girls and women liked, but because it's badly written, full of cultural appropriation and Unfortunate Implications, and the relationship dynamics are anything but healthy.

Seriously, Edward is a modern Jane Austen love interest?! Poor Miss Austen just turned over in her grave.