Subject: re: chapters 7-9
Author:
Posted on: 2024-01-22 17:22:53 UTC

I’m enjoying reading Act 2 much more than I did Act 1; you’ve improved noticeably between the two! Particularly in the realm of keeping the pacing of conversations going without long interruptions midway through. I was thinking the scene inside Kaito’s consciousness was dragging on a little too long, but honestly, Kaito’s mangled instruction/apology to Tanner at the end is a funny enough punchline that I wouldn’t change anything of the setup. I’m also glad to see that Kaito’s view of the Flowers as mafia bosses has been dispelled.

A very good line I liked: “Kaito sighed. Kaito sighed, and sighed, and panic left through his breath.” It communicates Kaito’s true emotional state of being close to a full-on panic attack, while also reinforcing how his ego leads him to lie to himself. (I’m only sighing. Repeatedly.) I also like that his collection of personality aspects refer to themselves as “Aspects of Kaito’s Psyche For The Prevention of Kaito’s Suffering.” Kaito really is so self-absorbed that his primary subconscious drive is to avoid anything negative getting directed at himself, with little empathy for others!

Up until part 8 here, I mostly thought Tanner was just a funny little guy, with his vague answers and physical clumsiness. It’s kind of sad to learn that his “pratfall” moments are intentional distractions to hide his own lack of confidence and fear. Honestly, both Tanner and Kaito stand to benefit a hell of a lot from sessions at FicPsych. Tanner lacks the confidence to confront Kaito’s ego, and Kaito lacks the empathy to give Tanner the support he needs, so they’re not going to be a big help to each other, if they don’t interact with other folks!

I’m very interested to see where Naomi’s arc is leading; how rare to see a Suvian in a PPC mission get a character arc! I love how you’ve made her aware of the distortions she’s caused through her narrative tampering: the band, the period, the Simpsons characters’ woodenness and lack of consistency. I especially like seeing her analyze her “relationship” with Ned, and question whether it can be real if it had to be scripted; plus, it implies there’s some canon-restoring value in simply reading the charges out, separate from the actual assassination. The in-universe justification for requiring the agents to read out charges has always been an arbitrary “it’s the rules,” so I like the implication here that the charges actually assist in restoring canon! But yeah, very interested to see where this plotline is leading Naomi in the end . . .

—doctorlit can’t blame Tanner for picking a cat as his disguise; after all, it’s right there in the song: ♪Everybody, everybody, everybody wants to be cat ♪

Reply Return to messages