Subject: Concrit Train!
Author:
Posted on: 2012-02-18 21:14:00 UTC

Being that I have watched only a few episodes of the show, this should be interesting. I'm going to go in order of when things come up, since I will be making notes while reading.

Chapter 1:

"Slow going," Glyph replied. "We've worked out the tweaks we needed to fix as far the central design goes." I believe you are missing an 'as' at the end of that line.

Did I misunderstand something, or did Rarity walk off across campus at some point and then reappear in the conversation as if she hadn't left?

I'm wondering where Fluttershy is during all of this. Surely the Mane Six are all involved.

Chapter 2:

Hilarious. I know Bronies are often college aged, but it hadn't occurred to me that someone might be sitting around swearing, drinking and smoking while they talk about MLP. It's so discordant. I love it.

Also, the appearance of the letter was inspired.

He managed to catch about half of it,. The rest and his Zippo dropped onto the grass. Two problems. 1) The comma at the end of that first sentence. 2) How do you catch half a scroll? These sentences could be clarified to make it more apparent that the scroll unraveled and had multiple pages, which is what I decided after reading it a few times.

Chapter 3:

I was expecting Terry from chapter 2 to be back in this one. I guess we'll catch up with him later.

"That question's a miite phi-lo-soph-i-cal, miss. Everything'll be explained inside. You best get along." I think you have an extra 'i' in there.

The left and right walls both had doors which were currently closed, leaving the unlit corridor before her as only direction to go—deeper into the building. I think it should be "the only direction to go."

Bright colorful banners hung from the corridor's ceiling light wrapped wires, occasionally punctuating the darkness with 'WELCOME!' and 'THIS WAY!'. There is a problem in this sentence right around "light wrapped wires". I am not quite sure what you were going for, so I don't know how to fix it.

the path form the doors Should be 'from'.

After watching a few still-unsure-on-their-hooves ponies walk though, Heather warily followed, descending into the dimly lit auditorium. Something is off in this sentence. I think it should be 'through' instead of 'though'.

and a several scattered throughout the various rows Take out the 'a' and you should be fine.

Suddenly, the lights went off. Kinda disappointed that we don't find out if some of the Ponies DO glow in the dark.

and momentarily he appeared behind the stand 'after a moment' would be better. Right now it seems like he appears behind the stand and then disappears.

The spotlight gags are good. I assume the CMC are running tech? They would not have been my first choice, but I am not usually going for comedy when I am doing tech.

Oh no! Blank flanks! The worst possible thing! :P

You have done an excellent job keeping the cast in character, though I wonder why Luna was even there. She didn't really add anything to the story.

The PPC ponies seem a little harsh for this environment, though I suppose that could just be an act to put the fear of the PPC into the students. I will have to wait and see how that pans out.

Overall:

The first half of chapter 3 was rough, due to some of the issues I pointed out earlier, but the story, descriptions, and characterization were excellent.

I am wondering what the classes are going to be, and which Ponies will be teaching what. I suppose I will have to read further to find out.

Keep up the good work.

-Phobos, 20% more concrit in 10 seconds flat

Reply Return to messages