My two cents

Sue Page Cleanup Results: Part 1 by Guvnor of Space on 2011-12-26 04:48:00 UTC Reply

This is going to be the first of two or three of these lists we will be posting over the course of our evaluation, and represents exactly one quarter of all Sue pages currently on the wiki. If anyone in the community feels a Sue page slated for deletion that they did not write deserves to be kept, speak up!

Note: Original Series Sues have automatic immunity from deletion, since the consensus seems to be that they are all notable. However, since they may need re-write, they will only appear on the list of pages to be kept after they have been reviewed by two people who both agree that no re-writing is needed.

The following Sues (for the purposes of these pages, Stus fall into the category of Sue) have been deemed by at least two individuals who have never written a Sue page before to not meet the criteria the community felt a Sue needed to meet in order to deserve a page. Total on this list: 22

Cordelia Driscol

Dragona

Elizabeth Bennet

Emily

Emily Smith

Erik Servint

Felicity Brown

Forlay

Fraya Montag

Heather Draconius

Icy

Jackson Earl Simon

Jayson

Jessica Luke

Kana

Kanami Kimura

Katherine May Gibbs

Kay-Cee Carter

Kayla "Kay" Troy

Kelly

Kirox, Lykas, and Lunavier

Kithra

The following Sues have been reviewed and found to meet the criteria to have their own page, but need some kind of work. Total on this list: 2

Deez- Page needs to be expanded

John Freeman- the links to the missions where he was killed are dead. Don’t know where to find replacements.

The following pages have been voted to be kept, with no work needed on the pages. Total on this list: 13

Damien

Deminica

Elvira Flameheart Magiseer

Emma Silverblade

Gem Stoned

Gemini Stone

Gwendolyn Elizabeth Huntington

Hanae

Honesah Hoononee Keemo

Isabella Pierce

Jaycacia Thornbyrd

Kayla Shepard

Laura

Opinion by Jacer on 2011-12-27 16:17:00 UTC Reply

I plug for Emily and Heather Draconius to be kept. Emily because of the character-turned-wraith aspect, and Heather because of the sheer level of WHAT.

Hrm by Guvnor of Space on 2011-12-28 05:58:00 UTC Reply

I can tell you, at least on Heather, that I don't consider her that special. I've read the mission in question (since I follow the exploits of Cadmar and company) and there really isn't that much special about Heather- she's a wraith, and long term possession has been known to cause nasty side effects. Granted, genderbending is unique, and yes, I was (slightly) on the fence on this one. However, her uniqueness seems to mostly deal with her importance to Cadmar, and the consensus us reviewers came to was that Sues whose only importance is to individual agents are not (usually) notable. I'd like to know what others think about this. If the community really likes this page, well, I think we should keep it.

As for Emily... maybe. Others should weigh in on that too, but I'm much less on the fence with her.

My two cents by EileenAlphabet on 2011-12-29 09:50:00 UTC Reply

Strictly my own opinions:

The thing with Heather is that she managed to posses Cadmar because of a faulty dummy. Which means that it had less to do with Heather and more to do with the dummy and the agents. It made for a superinteresting mission, but that doesn't necessarily translate to a superinteresting Sue.

About Emily: Wraits are well established, but I'll admit that I haven't seen other, who started out as OCs and then switched over to possessing a canon character. But it seem more like a variation on a theme, than something new.

Re: Sue Page Cleanup Results: Part 1 by Miah on 2011-12-27 05:46:00 UTC Reply

Would it be possible to include a brief summary about each?

Hm? by Guvnor of Space on 2011-12-27 06:41:00 UTC Reply

About what? As to who they are, or as to why they are being deleted/kept? If the former, I can provide links for all of them (although that's kind of time consuming, and they can all be found in the slain Sue category) but if the latter, well, I didn't even write down my reasons for deletions- it's a lot easier to say why a Sue should be kept than why it should be deleted, since keeping one involves something special you can point to, where as a deletions tend to be a lack of anything interesting to say about them.