3. Bad Grade by Sugarplumjellygum
Hermione goes to Snape's office to get him to change her Bad Grade and leaves with something worse.
"Absolutely disgraceful, Miss Granger. I expect this kind of tripe from Potter and Weasley, but..." Snape let a ladleful of Brawler's Broth trickle back into the cauldron and gaver Hermione a sneer. "I suppose we must make allowances for those of us with... less background... in the Arts."
Cue sniggers from the other side of the Potions Dungeon and outraged growls from the Gryffindors, mainly Ron and Harry. Hermione said nothing as Professor Snape scribbled a mark on her paper and let it fall back to the desk.
"He can't do that to you, Hermione! Your potion was loads better than Greengrass's or Zabini's, and they both got full marks!" Ron's outrage carried over onto the Grounds, where Hermione had accompanied him and Harry for the afternoon.
"It's not that bad, Ron. I mean, he always gives the Slytherins better marks than us. It's useless to get upset about it at this point, really, and it's only a P..."
Harry snorted, glancing up from his own Potions paper, which he'd been absently shredding from the corners in the whole walk, having gotten a P as well. "What's wrong with you, Hermione? Since when do you let Snape push you around like that? I mean, he as good as said right out that you're less of a witch because you're Muggle-born!"
Ron nodded furiously. "That's just-- that's not even a bad grade, that's... that's a Bad Grade!"
She frowned for a moment, then abruptly turned back to the castle.
"Wait-- Hermione! Where are you going?"
"Where do you think, Ron?" she called over her shoulder. "I'm going to get that grade fixed!"
Harry and Ron stared at each other for a second, shrugged, and turned back to the lake.
She paused at the Potions Dungeon. Why the panic? She'd done this in Charms at least three times, asked for a clearer explanation on an essay, talked to Professor Sprout about practical grades' weights against writing and theory... just because this was Potions, and Professor Snape, and... and...
Unable to finish the thought in a way that didn't involve leaving, immediately, Hermione took a deep breath and rapped sharply on the door.
"Come in," drawled the Professor. How does he manage to make his -voice- sneer? She grimaced and walked into the dungeon, determined not to let him upset her.
He glanced up for about a millisecond, and then returned to his desk. "Ah, Miss Granger. Here, of course, to complain that you are undeserving of ever being graded as less than perfect."
Hermione took a deep breath. "Well, sir, I really just wondered why my potion received a lower grade than anyone else's, even though there were other potions far less like the finished product, and it didn't seem like mine was that far off..." She trailed off. Snape hadn't looked up once, and continued to write on his parchment without pause. There was a long silence. Finally, he finished writing.
"Untrue, Miss Granger. Neville Longbottom received a D for his potion, and three Hufflepuffs from the period before yours-- ah, but you are a high and mighty Gryffindor, and no doubt inquiring as to the grades of the lower Houses is beneath you."
"Professor, we don't have ti--"
"As I was saying, Miss Granger," he continued, with a look that might have been a glare, if there had been any actual emotion in it, "Your main problem seems to be that you received a lower mark than any of the students in your own class-- any Slytherins."
There was a bit of a pause, as Hermione struggled to find the right words to answer this, without using words like 'favoritism' or 'unfair' or 'slimy git.'
"You may not have noticed this, Miss Granger, but your potions are not always deserving of full marks, despite the fact that you are a Gryffindor, and, therefore, can apparently do no wrong."
"I wasn't asking for full marks, Professor, just--"
"However, (and if you keep interrupting me, Miss Granger, you will receive a detention), if you had paid attention to anything I said in the beginning of the class, rather than scolding your friends for their juvenile doodles, you would have understood the theory of what I was saying, as Zabini did. Your potion may have looked the part of a Brawler's Broth more than his, but his was closer to the meaning of the potion itself."
"...Oh." She started to speak again, but Snape motioned for the paper, and she handed it to him.
"Now get out of my classroom, and next time you bother me outside of class, you will simply receive a detention." She glanced at the paper. The P had been revised to a T. "I do not have to explain my motives to you, Miss Granger. Goodbye."
She fled.
"So, did you get that grade changed, Hermione?"
She shot Harry a glare and swept past him up to the Girls' Dormitory. He looked back at Ron, bemused. "What'd I say?"