Whooooooahhhhh.... by
Lily Winterwood
on 2008-08-07 22:57:00 UTC
Reply
NOOOOOOOO! ANOTHER PERSON TO MASSACRE THE TOLKIEN LEGENDARIUM! MY PRECIOUSSSSSSS CANON!
Okay...why did they name a character after Agent Dafydd's ring? (And I suppose it's also Maglor's, but my Silm memories are rather rusty so tell me if I'm wrong.)
But it's not THAT bad, compared to other tripe I have seen. The author/ess knows little snippets of bookverse and Silmarillion knowledge. *peeks at review page* GO WANDERING CRITIC!!!
Re: Slaughter at will by
Wandering Critic
on 2008-08-02 18:45:00 UTC
Reply
Not the worst, by far, but it's definitely sporking material. After the squeeing reviews already up there, the author may be badly traumatized by mine (and should be grateful that I'm quite busy and didn't have time to give her story a thorough going-over). Y'know, I really should write a blog post about the people who see the whole world through their teenage perspective and have no concept that there is anything else out there, and who turn everything into a bad teen romance novel. I miss the old days; now, when the overwhelming majority of fanfic is written by semi-literate teenage girls who have never read a book in their lives, this stuff is the rule rather than the exception.