Subject: When I first heard that song,
Author:
Posted on: 2014-03-07 04:37:00 UTC

I thought that Elsa was going evil. I don't mean that as a bad thing, and in fact when I was watching I thought something along the lines of "Wow. This is probably the most well-structured and natural descent into villainy that I've ever seen in a movie." I knew that if she did, it wouldn't be permanent, both due to Disney law and the culmination of her character arc, but I'm still convinced that if she hadn't hit Anna in the heart and nearly killed her, Elsa would've at least temporarily turned evil. All the steps she took getting to that point, from the personal tragedies, to her sudden decision to not only accept but embrace what makes her unique after a life of repressing herself out of fear, to the path that had been set up for her and she had reluctantly prepared for all her life seemingly crashing down, to her decision to discard her old life and build herself a new identity, all has the makings of a really good villain origin story. It could also be backstory for a future protagonist, but we already had protagonists in Anna and Kristoff. (Maybe Elsa will be the central character in the now-pretty-much-inevitable sequel. That should be fun.)
It was due to Anna's idealism, Elsa's still-intact feelings toward her sister, and an unexpected revelation coupled with the onrush of a second psychological break that made Elsa realize how dangerous she was, and that was a turning point in her character. It also could very easily not have happened.

Elsa was already experiencing some self-denial, claiming that the cold had never bothered her when in fact, the cold, in the form of her powers, was originally the source of many of her problems. To break that down, she willingly discards and avoids considering important information about her past to become more free from her old troubles in the future. There's a slow but final motion from something like that to making decisions that your older self might not have approved of. Evil's not just a switch; there's not just one event that'll suddenly set someone off. It creeps up on you, and you don't notice that you've suddenly gone against the ideals and morals of others because you've come to believe in something new. They say it's wrong? Maybe they see it that way, but they're also the same people who were giving you problems in the past, right? If it hadn't been for them, you'd be as happy as you are now back then. They made you live in fear, and you know that that's wrong. So, no, you're not wrong. They're wrong. And suddenly, you have a hard time turning back.

Plus, just listen to those lyrics. Like, actually listen to them. "My power flurries through the air into the ground"? "I am one with the wind and sky"? "No right, no wrong, no rules for me"? That is straight-up unimpeachable villainous posturing.

Reply Return to messages