Subject: Occam's Razor suggests...
Author:
Posted on: 2014-03-03 17:01:00 UTC

That if we see a man-shaped, leafy entity called a Greenman, it's probably a Greenman (or Green Man), not a zebra some other, more exotic thing. Jay and Acacia didn't appear to think it needed much of an explanation, so the obvious answer is most likely the correct one.

The closest I can come to an alternative explanation is the Greenwitch from the book by the same name in the Dark Is Rising series. The Greenwitch is... pretty much the same thing as a Green Man: a human-shaped construct of branches and leaves, in this case made to be thrown into the ocean in a ritual to ensure a bountiful harvest. Her name is even spelled as one word, like the Greenman in TOS, and I think she has a degree of sentience due to Wild Magic or something; I'm not really sure. It's been ages since I read those books.

I'm not personally interested in making the Greenman's identity more complicated than it needs to be, though. Not everything needs volumes of explanation, especially if it's only come up the once in over ten years. If someone wants to write about lightsaber instruction and bring the guy back, that's awesome, but otherwise I'm fine with him just being a guy Jay and Acacia met once and didn't really get along with. *shrug*

~Neshomeh

Reply Return to messages