Subject: I agree about the Valar.
Author:
Posted on: 2014-02-20 13:39:00 UTC

I'm looking at what almost has to be Ulmo in Chapter III, and wishing the rest of them were more like that. On that score, Yavanna actually works (and I do like the way she has no mouth), but the 4/5 (depending on whether the one on the right in III is supposed to be Aule again) are just... humans with magicky attributes.

If (ha ha) I ever get that far in my 'Lay of Earendil/War of Wrath' script, I plan to show the Mahanaxar originally inhabited by pure 'attribute' forms of the Valar - so Vaire would be a spider's web (but no spider!) stretched between a memorial stone (Mandos) and... well, I don't have them all decided, obviously. Then switch to human form later on. I'd really like to see someone render the whole bunch of them as incarnations of their attributes - but I'm hard-pressed to picture that as anything other than 'and Yavanna's a talking tree, and...'. So maybe this actually is best. Like I say, if it weren't for the deer association, Yavanna would be brilliant.

I guess it's about breaking out of your mental images. How do you render The Weeper as anything other than a woman in a grey cloak? A small black cloud out of Winnie-the-Pooh?

hS

Reply Return to messages