Subject: The jury's still out here...
Author:
Posted on: 2013-12-08 21:48:00 UTC
It's good for a snort, but I'm also on the fence.
- Goodfic or badfic? You decide! by on 2013-12-08 10:35:00 UTC Reply
-
How about a video? by
on 2013-12-09 05:35:00 UTC
Reply
This is a 12 minute YouTube epic, so make yourself comfortable. Beware: contains strong language.
I'd say it borders on crackfic, but all of the characters are pretty OOC.
On the other hand, I nearly laughed myself to death. Make of that what you will. -
I'd say it's crack. by
on 2013-12-09 01:00:00 UTC
Reply
I kind of prefer my crack to be improbable Sherlock Holmes or Star Trek crossovers, but the grammar is acceptable on average, so the fic is innocent. :D
-
The jury's still out here... by
on 2013-12-08 21:48:00 UTC
Reply
It's good for a snort, but I'm also on the fence.
-
Eh. by
on 2013-12-08 21:27:00 UTC
Reply
It's crackfic, and was intended to be parody/humor. The two things I look for in badfic are OOC and Mary Sues, and given the crackfic premise, no one was OOC and there were no OCs therefore no Sues. I don't think it's particuarly funny, but that's very much YMMV. Failing at a humorous goal doesn't make something badfic unless the humor is of a quality that no one should enjoy (e.g. rape jokes).
Bottom line, not badfic, but I wouldn't call it goodfic either. Maybe there's just some things that just don't fall in either category.
And since this is the inevitable question when putting such things up for debate - no, I don't think it's sporkable. It's not great, but it's hardly bad enough.