Subject: My thoughts.
Author:
Posted on: 2013-10-24 13:48:00 UTC

I've no idea about Daphne Greengrass, having only ever seen passing mentions of her in fanfic. It might just be that people associate her strongly with Draco/the Slytherin creed, but know very little about her - therefore making her perfect for "development" by pairing her with the hero.

However, the Ron-bashing has some theories behind it. The most enduring one I've seen is that he's not "special" the way Harry and Hermione are; Harry is the Boy Who Lived, the hero, the central figure, and Hermione is brilliant, pretty (they're usually going off Emma Watson's looks) and confident. Therefore, Harry is better than Ron because he's special, and Ron is ordinary and only bickers with her and is piggish (remember how much he likes his food?) and clearly does not deserve such a paragon of womanhood as Hermione. Essentially, Harry is the bigger prize because he's the hero and therefore Hermione must only ever settle for the bigger prize. But because canon says she and Ron love each other, people have to bash Ron to make Harry actually look like the more suitable partner and force Hermione into his arms.

Manipulative!Dumbledore is generally a way for people who want Harry to do his own thing let him do it. It's true that there was a fair bit of manipulation going on in the series by our twinkly-eyed Headmaster to get everything ready for the ultimate elimination of Voldemort - but it was done with good intentions. A lot of ficwriters ignore that, or blow it out of proportion, or twist it to make Dumbledore Teh Evulz so that Harry will break free and go on his merry way, building up his own power base and challenging people to gain even more power. Basically, it's to give Harry a power trip, because that's exactly what modest, unassuming, loving Harry really wants. Yup.

Hermione's parents being named Dan and Emma is just a bit of fandom meta, I guess - "LOL, we'll name them after Harry and Hermione's actors, aren't we original and witty?" seems to be the idea.

My apologies for the slight Wall O'Text... I get verbose about the Potterverse.

Reply Return to messages