Have an animate origami frog as befits a returnbie, crafted of what looks supiciously like a page from the Red Book.

It was pinched from the Tanz der Vampire fandom.

*high-fives* Here's a banana from Super Mario Sunshine!

Did I already give you one of my feathers? If not, have one anyway! And a complimentary kit of Spikes just because.

Here, have this cup of tea. No, it's not going to try to eat you, why are you looking at me like that?

Have a shovel enchanted with a Dark Priest's favor!

Note that Voyd Industries takes no responsibility if using this shovel summons priestly succubi.

Here, have a woolly Yoshi. They don't come in orange, sadly; you can pick green, light blue or pink.
SMBX is that fangame, right? It's going to be pretty redundant in about a month. :-p *is way too excited for Super Mario Maker*

I remember you, dude! :D

You deserve a prize for returning... Here, have a Head That's Always Screaming

Welcome back! Take this freshly-made plate of SPaGhetti as a gift!