Subject: You don't necessarily have to write the accent at all.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-07-05 15:46:00 UTC

I'm assuming you're not just writing the character so you'll have the challenge of a phonetic accent, correct?

Speaking from experience in the POTC fandom...phonetic accents are very, very hard to do well. I see it all the time, even in otherwise well-written fics, where poor Jack Sparrow ends up sounding like anything from street teenager to Southern to Scottish. Yes, Scottish.

On that occasion, Potcsues had some mightily helpful advice for prospective accent-writers:

Hasunoutena: Is dialogue always written like that in PotC fics? Because after I read the snippets of that fic, I can't get the Scottish accent out of my head. I'm sure that wasn't the intention.

Potcsues: Well, not always.

Some people just don't feel like bothering with anyone having an accent at all and get caught up in making everyone speak "proper" English. Unfortunately, to make someone speak proper English one needs to have paid attention in an English class at least a few times in the course of their lifetime, so that never turns out well either.

It's very rare that someone just alludes to an accent, like people who know what the **** they're doing do when writing accents in fiction.


As for me, I wouldn't say that phonetic accents can't ever be written well under any circumstances, but I wouldn't advise anyone to try it without a strong background in linguistics or at least a few years listening to the accent on a regular basis. In addition to alluding to an accent, what will help distinguish your character's speech will be the word choices and colloquial expressions that he uses, which is usually more than enough for the readers to get the idea.

Ќ—Araeph

Reply Return to messages