Subject: Ja. (Also known as OH SWEET CELESTIA, WHAT HAVE YOU DONE.)
Author:
Posted on: 2013-01-25 09:32:00 UTC
Luna had voice problems for majority of one episode as "Real Luna" and shouted as "Evil Luna" because she was the designated villain for those two episodes. Besides that, by 'quieter', I was referring to the fact that she very rarely says more than what's necessary - Celestia seems to favor a more roundabout way of explaining things, whereas Luna tends to say what's on her mind (or attempt to, when she isn't being interrupted) without waxing lyrical.
As for the jealousy argument, I'd say she had a fair bit of reason for getting a bit piqued that her sister was getting all the glory - from what we've seen in her most recent appearance, she not only brings the night but is also capable of venturing into the dreams of any pony she chooses, which likely means that Scootaloo's nightmares are not the first to be chased away with a bit of sensible advice from Luna. Yet as far as the canon states, the majority of the ponyfolk either didn't appreciate this or did very little (if anything) to show their appreciation - likely they took her for granted, since the only time they saw her was probably in their dreams. Celestia was a more solid figure who appears when everypony's awake; it's harder to take a pony as just something that exists when she's actively walking amongst her subjects while they're awake to appreciate it. I'd even go so far as to say that many ponies probably even began seeing Luna as a pleasant dream sent to them by Celestia - particularly the older ponyfolk, if we follow the logic that some people/ponies tend to try to find more... concrete reasons for things like dreams and voices in their minds.
Speaking of Celestia~
Yes, she absolutely did what needed to be done to protect Equestria... But. I find two things very difficult to believe: First, there is no way Luna woke up one evening, decided on the flip of a coin she was mad enough to shroud the world in darkness, went Nightmare Moon, and was imprisoned... all due to the boiling-up of intense jealousy that took place in one night. There had to have been a build-up. We could be talking about centuries of nights spent painting wonderful, starry skies and guarding the dreams of others; of days spent sleeping and watching her sister received the bulk of their ponies' praise. Which translates, I think, into just as many years of Luna becoming more and more jealous of her sister as time went on. Eventually, that built-up jealousy exploded, forcing Celestia into action.
Which did not, I believe, have to be the way things worked out, because the second thing I find very hard to believe is that Celestia could completely overlook how jealous her sister was becoming. Even if it wasn't centuries of build-up, there is no way Luna went from happy-go-lucky to BAM NOW I AM EVIL in a night, which I think means there's no way Celestia missed how unhappy her sister was becoming. True, the canon states that Celestia "tried to reason with [Luna]", but Luna is not hot-headed. Not to the extent that her sister's reasoning with her would not carry at least some weight.
And, for that matter, why did Celestia apparently never do more than reason with Luna? Where were the requests to remember how important Luna is to Equestria? Where were any festivals held, parades led, or statues erected in Luna's honor? True, Luna works a full night's shift just as Celestia works a full day, which means Luna is most probably nocturnal (in other words, she probably sleeps during the day) - but that doesn't mean that she didn't try every way she could to garner some sympathy when she was awake, even if the only way to do that without irritating anypony was to dreamwalk. The fact that she is nocturnal also does not mean no celebrations could be held for her at night. Clearly the fact that most ponies are diurnal (nighttime sleepers) has no effect on how many of them are willing to participate in Nightmare Night festivities, nor did those shown in the pilot episodes seem terribly opposed to staying up all night to watch the sunrise for the Summer Solstice celebration. Would it have been terribly much to ask that they show the same consideration a night or two now and then the honor everything Luna's done for them? I'm not saying Celestia should have forced her subjects to like Luna, but I certainly think more could have been done to share the enormous spotlight Celestia enjoyed even back a thousand years ago.
(Please note that all of that was not intended as an attack, and if anything came off as chilly or even a bit spiteful, I apologize. You hit my debate button. I CANNOT RESIST THE DEBATE BUTTON. XD
Also, do explain why you love the show. I want to hear~)