Subject: Ooh, this should be fun.
Author:
Posted on: 2013-01-25 11:26:00 UTC
*cracks knuckles*
Alright. Let's do this.
Ah, so by 'quiet,' you mean 'direct,' yes? Alright, I can see that. I see Celestia as the more Public Relations type of the two, who likes to express her opinion in fancy, more round-about ways. Luna on the other hoof has a meteor shower to plan for next week, and an eclipse in three days, so let's get on with it, shall we? That and the fact she did not have opportunity to learn how to communicate well to the public, due to everypony being asleep when she was around.
As for Nightmare Moon (henceforth known as NMM) and Luna's turn to jealousy, I have a theory (WARNING, FANON INCOMING!) that connects to dreams and nightmares that could solve our problem, with some Word of Faust to back it up. NMM was not just a state of being Luna became, it was a completely separate creature or entity that took control of her, like Venom from Spiderman. NMM is the cumulation of negative emotions brought out in nightmares. Fear, hatred, self-loathing, and most important, jealousy. Over hundreds of years, ponies' nightmares continued to feed the beast, infecting Luna with these emotions, due to being the Princess of the Night, and dreams being under her jurisdiction. The mass of dream-polution eventually created a personality for itself, and began to whisper in Luna's ears. It played off Luna's fear of not being loved, of being hated by everypony. It fed her self-doubt, making her think she did not deserve praise. It caused her to become angry at the people it told here was responsible for her not being loved by everypony, those ponies who give all credit to Celestia. It slowly, over a long corse of time, corrupted her, gaining a strong footing in Luna's mind so it could not only have a host, but spread these emotions through all Equestria. Once Luna snapped, and wanted revenge against those who wronged her, NMM replaced Luna in her mind, and began to cause not only the sun to never rise again, but to spread her Aura of Evil through all of Equestria. Fear would grasp the land, and the strength of Nightmare Moon would only grow.
NMM's plan would have worked, had Celestia not sent her sister to the moon itself, Luna's land of power and control, to slowly strengthen her sister, and weaken the grasp of NMM. Now that Luna is free of NMM, she is making sure it cannot rise again, by stopping the Nightmares at the source. That is why she appeared to Scootaloo to stop her nightmares, the TRUE nightmares of Rainbow Dash not accepting Scootaloo as a sister or mentor, and all the connotations that brings. As a seres of reams? Not too harmful, but given time and an ability to let the Nightmares take hold...
As for Celestia's lack of observation or intervention: I honestly think she did not see it as a problem when it started. Luna began to feel a little jealous, a little more mopey. Just provide some support and it will go away soon. Celestia spoke words of encouragement, prompting Luna to make the ponies know about the night by putting on spectacular astronomical events that can only be seen at night, wowing them into respecting her. What she didn't know was that she was feeding the beast until it was too late. Luna began to do more reckless behavior with her responsibilities, keeping the moon up while the sun is up, trying to extend the night, and so on. Now Celestia began to get cross at Luna. Why was she doing her job wrong all the sudden? She needs to do it right, darn it! Voices were raised, Celestia begins to see that her sister is not quite right and tries to stop it, but it's too late.
Poor Luna snapped.
And so Celestia had no other choice. She had to banish her sister to the moon, so Luna could build back her strength.
Could this have been prevented with more public recognition of Luna? Perhaps, but strong feelings of jealousy, especially those fueled by self-doubt and tacky purple tufts of smoke, find a way to ignore logic and blatant truths that point to the contrary. They will find those things that support their theories of the world, even if they are invalid. Basically, once it passed a particular point, it was too late for Luna, and it was not a problem before it crossed that point, so Celestia felt she had no reason to spread all this awareness for Luna that Luna did not want done in the first place.
Well, I think that about covers the debate aspect. Now, as for why I like the show. The animation is stellar, the voice actors are phenomenal and convey so much in their voices, the characters are strong and fun, and the show is funny. However, I think the biggest draw for me was a good cartoon who's characters are dumber than a bag of rocks, use toilet humor for cheap laughs (Spongebob, I look at you) or uses immense amounts of violence, sex, alcohol, and cynicism. This show does not speak down to any audience, nor does it have 'adult' humor, but humor I understand now that as a kid I would not know. I believe Bronyville decided that the show has very witty humor, to which I would agree and point out the use of several slapstick elements usually seen in older cartoons. The subtle references and horse puns also add to the enjoyment of the show.
Of corse the extremely vast, creative, accepting, kind, fun fandom helps too.