Subject: I really should've closed that italics tag. (nm)
Author:
Posted on: 2014-09-18 19:48:00 UTC
-
Fill... the... Plotholes? by
on 2014-09-18 11:32:00 UTC
Reply
So it seems we haven't done this since - brace yourselves - May 2011. That's terrible.
This is Fill the Plotholes. It's the oldest PPC game; it's been going since before I joined; and it is awesome fun.
How it works is this: I list a bunch of summaries, riddled with the plotholes that usually infest summaries. You pick one of these summaries and write a story that fills those plotholes. It can be an interpretation that makes the story actually good, or it can be satire which draws out every single error and implausibility.
This does not (normally) involve PPC agents, though they're not strictly forbidden. Nor does it involve reading the actual story - some of these look like they might be quite good, but the summaries are plotholicious. No, you don't need Permission. Yes, multiple people can do the same summary. No, there's no need to 'reserve' a summary; just write it and post it. (No, you don't need a beta, and no, it doesn't need to be very long. This is a fun game)
For this round, I've chosen summaries from the Great Trifecta of PPC traditional canons: The Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, and Discworld. All summaries are taken from the first page of the relevant category on Fanfiction.net. Enter at your peril...
The Lord of the Rings
1/ Struck by an Arrow
WARNING: Legomance, but no tenth-walker and all that jazz... Story of a girl who's struck by lightning and transferred to Mirkwood, stumbling upon some of the most fearsome elves in all of Middle Earth. How will she explain what happened to the Elvenking? Or to herself? Sorry, the summary isn't great, but PLEASE give my story a try! Thank you! :)
2/ Children of Vána and Oromë
Lara and Jack are the Children of two of the Valar. They are destined to meet their fate in Middle-Earth, not in England. When one night, Nienna, the mourner of the Valar is sent to inform them of their fate, taking them over the bridge with her. They end up in Arda and are changed, they find their fate but they face some difficulties. Proudly Slash Free.
3/ The Daughter of Elrond
The Ring has been stolen and a daughter of Elrond is missing. Rated T for possible language.
4/ The Morning Star
During the war of the ring, the woodland realm lives troubled times. Between war and fear appears a child that might change the course of what would seem like a predictable tale.
5/ Side by side with his dwarf
Legolas and Gimli are great friends but Aragorn knows that they are more than that he just needs to make them realise it.
Harry Potter
6/ Destiny Flame
Abandoned by his family for having a darkness clinging to him, Harry jumps at the chance to go to Hogwarts. Unfortunately the twin that his parents favoured over him spreads rumours about his darkness, saying that they had abandoned him for a perfectly good reason. Struggling through a world where almost no one likes him, Harry manages to become something great. Eventually.
7/ A Father's Love
Abraxas and Lucius get sent back in time thanks thnaks to a potion, while they are there they try and find Harry, also both of then look like they are 15 and 17 years old, this story and some of the characters are from my idea of what happened after deathly hallows ended. If I said anymore I would give away the story, so if you want to find out what happens plz R&R :)
8/ Elemental Girls at Hogwarts
When 4 new students going by the names of; Summer Flame, Rosely Forest, Sky Thundercloud and Icey Tsunami enter Hogwarts as 2nd years. They have to defeat old Villains and deal with Love. Will their secret be found out and who will fall for who?
9/ Worth It (if you stick around)
It's possible to be such a critic that you lose sight of what could possibly keep you. It's a good thing his heart is made of brave scarlet, or he would never go searching for clarity. A story in which life just happens.
10/ One Year
Robbie was scared, he was nervous. Leaving America to head to England to go to Hogwarts, his parents told him it would be alright. But he felt like he would be a ghost, joining Gryffindor might just change all of that. Meeting some new people and making friends might not be so scary after all, but what can one 11 year old do?
Discworld
11/ Twisted In Every Way
12-year-old Victoria and her twin brother James are orphaned because of a freak "accident". But what will "dear little Victoria" do to get into the guild that wants her brother as a member? Be warned, it is rather disturbing at the beginning. Please Review!
12/ Zoo Tales
Posibly the beginning of a new cycle set in the City Zoo. No sex except for the animals and not much swearing. Though watch where you stand...
13/ The Discworld Tarot
NC "DEATH" AT chap. 15! The Tarot Pack is either a neat psychological tool, or it offers genuine portals to the world of The Other, or it's a good way for plausible bluffers like me to earn 20 quid a reading. Or it could be about Discworld characters...NOW WITH MINOR ARCANA! (building slowly but surely.)
14/ The Sanest of the Bunch
"We are the only sane ones here, aren't we?" Unfortunately, the answer was yes, Toad and Jeannie were the only sane ones there.
15/ Dancing Lessons
The Patrician is dead. Long live the Patrician. Rated for mild language.
Enjoy!
hS -
A couple. by
on 2014-09-20 15:54:00 UTC
Reply
4/ The Morning Star
During the war of the ring, the woodland realm lives troubled times. Between war and fear appears a child that might change the course of what would seem like a predictable tale.
-
The gathered elves all hushed their conversation as Elrond re-entered the room, carrying a swaddled bundle. Then the room filled with questions, harshly whispered.
"Is it true?"
"Does she have the mark?"
"Is she the chosen one?"
"What am I doing here?" asked Legolas. "I don't usually live in the same city as Elrond. I'm confused as to which forest realm this is."
"I'm reasonably certain I shouldn't be here, either," said Aegnor.
"Quit complaining," said a Narnian centaur.
"Silence!" Elrond called. "This child bears the foretold mark! She is the chosen one! The one to end the conflict!"
In a flash of light, the child transformed into a fully grown (and clothed) woman. "It is I," she spoke.
"And how will you stop this war?" demanded a Smurf.
"Simple. There can be no war where there is no setting for one." The Chosen One lowered herself to hands and knees.
She dropped her face the the grass.
And began to eat the planet.
The crowd cried out louder and louder in alarm. Legolas grabbed Elrond's arm. "Lord Elrond! What can we do to stop this?"
"We cannot stop this." Elrond slowly turned to the younger elf. He was now wearing sunglasses. "It is inevitable."
-
12/ Zoo Tales
Posibly the beginning of a new cycle set in the City Zoo. No sex except for the animals and not much swearing. Though watch where you stand...
-
All around him, there were tortoises humping, and chickens humping, and ducks humping, and goats humping (though this was really just a dominance display between females). The prairie dogs were probably humping, though they had the decency to do so underground.
"Why, this isn't Discworld," said doctorlit. "This is just work." -
{X D by
on 2014-09-20 17:00:00 UTC
Reply
I was chuckling all the way through both of these. It seems you have a gift for the surreal. Nice job. ^_^
(Incidentally, I have seen tortoises humping at the Lincoln Park Zoo. Quite possibly one of the strangest things I've ever seen. They make a really odd noise. Until then, I did not know tortoises ever made noise. O.o )
~Neshomeh -
Re: {X D by
on 2014-09-26 16:09:00 UTC
Reply
Rather slow, eh? Ever seen how the tortoise on top rolls of about a hundred times, in slow motion?
-
I guess there's only one time worth making noise? by
on 2014-09-21 05:34:00 UTC
Reply
The tortoises here in Arizona could work as a thermometer. Too hot, or too cold? Taking shelter. Otherwise, tortoise sexy times. I get to see it a lot, since we have a separate, tortoise-only petting zoo next to our traditional one (where I worked up until midway through this month).
Mmm. Forgot to add a joke about swearing to the second one, 'cause zookeepers swear like sailors. (Or perhaps sailors have been swearing like zookeepers all along?)
When are we doing an Arizona Gathering so I can sneak you all into my zoo? "Hey, [doctorlit's boss at zoo], I need an entire day off and about thirty-five entrance passes! How about?" -
Sounds like fun! by
on 2014-09-20 03:43:00 UTC
Reply
9/ Worth It (if you stick around)
It's possible to be such a critic that you lose sight of what could possibly keep you. It's a good thing his heart is made of brave scarlet, or he would never go searching for clarity. A story in which life just happens.
There was a painting at Hogwarts that never moved, no matter how long the students might stare at it. There didn't appear to be anything remarkable about it aside from how it hung on the wall. Though it was a depiction of a heavily forested landscape, it had been placed on the wall as if it were a portrait. Altered as it was, the trees took on the appearance of scraggly green bristles on a massive brush, the rolling knolls became green pustules, and the clouded sky became a sloppy imitation of a waterfall. It was appalling.
It was no wonder that few wasted the time to observe it; however, it retained a certain amount of intrigue for the students with more artistic leanings. Dean Thomas was no exception.
"Why would there be a Muggle painting at Hogwarts?" he asked, pausing in front of the painting, as well as nearly causing Seamus to crash into him in the process.
"Probably for the same reason you're still lolling around looking at it," Seamus snipped, irritated by his near miss. "It's weird. Weird things tend to stick around Hogwarts."
"Fair enough, I guess." Dean continued to watch the painting, waiting for any sign that it might spring to life. He did not look as if he planned to move any time soon, much to Seamus's dismay.
"I reckon that Potions will start in a few minutes," Seamus prodded.
"Yes, I think so," Dean answered absently.
"Don't you think we should, I don't know, actually go? I don't much like the idea of losing twenty house points."
That got Dean's attention. He snorted, turning away from the painting at last. "You'd lose them the first time you blew up your draught anyway," he said.
"Oh yeah? I bet you a Galleon that I don't blow up a single thing today."
Laughing, Dean started walking to class once more. "I'll take that bet. I hope you're not saving up for Hogsmeade, Finnigan. You won't have two knuts to rub together by the trip if you keep throwing your money away like this."
"Very funny. I'll have you know that I have great odds today. Hermione told me that we aren't working with anything that reacts violently in Potions this week, modifying Cheering Charms isn't going to make anyone spontaneously combust, and I can't exactly set a transfigured mirror on fire, now can I?" Seamus grinned. "Just watch, I'll be flush by the end of the day."
Seamus proceeded to set a record for himself in producing four explosions in one day, only one of which was magical in nature.
[Time skip of doom and subsequent abrupt transitions because this is already longer than intended and I regret everything]
Later, Dean returned to the motionless painting. Down the hallway he could hear the clamour of students returning to their common rooms from the Great Hall. Sometimes he stayed as late as he could when it was a mealtime, but he left as quickly as possible just as often. There weren't many times when the hallways were free of students, save for the dead of night, and breaking curfew had long since lost its air of rebellion. It just felt nice to be alone sometimes.
Unaccompanied as he was, Dean had all the time he needed to observe the painting. He spent most of it tilting his head to the side. The first thing he had concluded was that it was beautiful from the correct perspective, but the way it was placed would prompt tears from its creator. He had entertained the notion of it being a sort of modern art, but had ascertained that it was much too old.
The second thing he ascertained was that it was hiding a door.
Dean had spent years living with a mother who was extremely fond of daytime telly, so he felt he was something of an aficionado regarding hidden passages and forbidden affairs. Knowing that the two were almost always intertwined, Dean found himself unwilling to open the painting door. He had no desire to see people snogging behind the painting, especially considering he was just as guilty of liaisons behind tapestries and in passages of all sorts as any unfortunate couple he might spy.
Considering these factors, he very slowly and deliberately knocked on the wall to the left of the landscape. When no answer was forthcoming, and there was a definite absence of students rushing out of the painting, he decided to take a chance. He took one deep breath and opened the door.
"Well, that's anticlimactic."
Before him lay a round, nearly bare room. The only thing adorning its walls was a single scarlet cape, embroidered with a heart, and a piece of parchment pinned to it. Upon further examination, the paper read, "Thif is to fay that Gregory shalle ne'er lay eye on his cloak if he e'er again mocks the artes. - Professor Claerty Hathorne"
[Surprise. I wrote this monstrosity to lead up to passive aggressive 16th century professor shenanigans.] -
On canon/fanon by
on 2014-09-20 13:03:00 UTC
Reply
Interesting little tale! Nice ending, too..
Just wondering, does it ever specifically state in the books that Seamus is a pyromaniac? I can't remember reading it anywhere, yet in lots of different fanfics he seems to have that talent. Most memorably, HPatAotDMKMDL (yes, long title, be glad I abbreviated it) in which he manages to blow up a Slytherin girl's pumpkin juice from 3 table away, giving the explanation "Backwash" and refusing to elaborate. -
Regarding alternative source material by
on 2014-09-20 17:57:00 UTC
Reply
I had always thought it was fanon until I decided to re-read the series and have a marathon of the HP movies. I usually derive most of my information from the books, but on this rare occasion I synthesised information from both the movies and the books.
The exact quote from the movie ran along the lines of, "Why don't you confer with Mr Finnigan? As I recall, he has a particular proclivity for pyrotechnics."
The book is far less dramatic in its depictions, stating that, "Seamus got so impatient that he prodded it with his wand and set fire to it." It was never stated whether this fire was accidental or purposeful.
I had never pictured his powers of incidental conflagration being so great that he could accidentally set something three tables away ablaze, but that's due to my own theories. I like to imagine that half of it is inflating the inside joke, and half of it is truly an accident. In any case, his experience with fire, explosions, and the like surely served him well during the war.
(I cannot begin to decipher that fic title, but I love guessing anyway. Harry Pooter at Attack on Titan: Dark Magic Kills Many Dead Lozenges?) -
Nowhere close. by
on 2014-09-21 01:46:00 UTC
Reply
The full title is (Harry Potter and the) Attack of the Deranged, Mutant, Killer Monster Dark Lord.
And, yea verily it is made of win. It is brilliantly funny. Go read it! -
That was almost a punchline. Brava. (nm) by
on 2014-09-20 04:28:00 UTC
Reply
-
I forgot to proofread. by
on 2014-09-20 04:27:00 UTC
Reply
Therefore there are some odd tense changes, forgotten capitalisations on specialty words such as 'knut', and other bits and bobs. Whoops.
One lives and learns, I suppose, but I am still suitably chastened.
I guess it goes to show that beta readers and self-editing are both indispensable tools. -
#1 Fill (that is, a fill for #1...) and also for #5 by
on 2014-09-19 17:49:00 UTC
Reply
1/ Struck by an Arrow
WARNING: Legomance, but no tenth-walker and all that jazz... Story of a girl who's struck by lightning and transferred to Mirkwood, stumbling upon some of the most fearsome elves in all of Middle Earth. How will she explain what happened to the Elvenking? Or to herself? Sorry, the summary isn't great, but PLEASE give my story a try! Thank you! :)
"Your king--he is a king?--well, he's probably still wrapped in vines. You shouldn't startle people, you know. Especially mages." Trisana Chandler plunked her fists on her hips and glared up at the tall man (one of many) in front of her. "And speaking of mages--I'm a mage. So you'd better put me back where I came from."
No one moved. In fact, everyone stared.
"Do I have something on my face?"
This got them to exchange glances, at least, but she might as well have been talking to...to...to snakes. Only these people wouldn't even hiss at her.
"Listen," Tris said, doing her best to keep the desperation out of her voice, "if you don't send me back, I'll get angry. Really angry. You won't like what happens when I'm angry."
The leader blinked at her. "Do you mean to threaten us?" He raised his bow until the nocked arrow pointed at her heart.
Tris' voice raised in annoyance. "I don't mean to threaten you. I don't need to. I just want you to know what you're up against." The arrow stayed where it was; the man's eyes narrowed. At least he'd spoken? "Stop that," Tris added, jabbing a finger at the weapon. "Just put me back. Now. Before I really get angry."
Today had been a bad day. The lightning had definitely been fun--strong and wild and rippling hot, tasting faintly of rain--but the richly dressed man stumbling out of nowhere and proclaiming loudly that there were no tenth-walkers or jazz had been a complete surprise. He hadn't gotten himself wrapped in vines until he managed to startle Briar into ruining an entire pot of burn salve. The plant mage had wrapped him in progressively more vines in a growing attempt to keep him silent and still.
(This stand-off continued for rather a while, really. No one quite knew how to set things right. No one quite knew how to bring up Tris' hair, either, which stood straight up where it wasn't braided, and crawled with seed lightning besides.)
*
Lightning suggested Tris to me. Very strongly, in fact. I'm not sure this really came out the way I wanted it to, but it's also my first time writing Tris, so that probably affected it. Hope you enjoyed nonetheless...and sorry for the general lack of Legomance, I couldn't make it fit with the length. Feel free to picture it somehow working out eventually, if you'd like.
-----
5/ Side by side with his dwarf
Legolas and Gimli are great friends but Aragorn knows that they are more than that he just needs to make them realise it.
"I do not understand this," Legolas said once they had attained privacy. "Has he taken leave of his wits? What could cause him to say such things?"
"Perhaps 'tis the stress of ruling," suggested Gimli. "It weighs on him, we have seen this--"
"But to suggest that--!" Legolas' hands waved about in unusual frustration. "It is not only absurd but physically impossible!"
"Peace, Legolas." The Dwarf waited until his friend was more collected before he spoke again. "Perhaps he means it as a joke."
"A joke."
"Aye." Gimli warmed to this theme, gesticulating broadly. "Grown weary with the formality of royal audiences, he has turned his mind to play. And what better way to relax than to play at convincing his friends--"
"I see no humor in this," Legolas protested, but Gimli shook his head.
"Perhaps you need not, friend Legolas. After all, it is his own amusement that Aragorn seeks."
"If this is indeed a joke," Legolas put in.
Gimli nodded reluctantly. "If it is indeed a joke, and not a failing in his sanity."
For some time there was silence. At length, Legolas spoke.
"We should alert the Queen, if nothing else."
Gimli's eyebrows shot upwards. "And how do you propose to explain this to her, Master Elf?"
"We tell her what he said," Legolas replied firmly. "We tell her, and we explain that we suspect a break in his sanity. Should it indeed be a joke, he will laugh all the harder; and should it be the stress of ruling, Arwen will see it and take measures to correct it. This shall be our course of action--if you agree."
Gimli thought it over, and then nodded. "It seems a sensible idea. Very well--I am agreed. When shall we approach her?"
"At once." Legolas straightened his already-straight clothing, and turned toward the door. "There is no time to lose."
Gimli nodded his agreement once more, and they left the room side by side.
What Arwen Undómiel would say to their claims of Aragorn's attempts to convince them that a Dwarf and an Elf were in fact blood brothers, neither preferred to imagine. Their only hope was that she would believe them.
*
Hey, it doesn't spell out what this 'more than that' is. I'm perfectly justified in claiming that Aragorn's trying to convince them that they're directly related biologically.
Your choice whether he's insane, playing a joke, or something else entirely. It's all up in the air.
-----
As a final note--please excuse or point out any OOCness. Tris was kind of hard to write, and I tried to base Gimli and Legolas mainly on the books rather than the movies. -
*cracks knuckles* by
on 2014-09-19 17:02:00 UTC
Reply
Man, it has been awhile. Let's see what I've got.
11. "Twisted In Every Way"
12-year-old Victoria and her twin brother James are orphaned because of a freak "accident". But what will "dear little Victoria" do to get into the guild that wants her brother as a member? Be warned, it is rather disturbing at the beginning. Please Review!
Victoria made the final adjustment, and her foot popped into place behind her head. She was twisted into a perfect human pretzel.
"There! See?" she said, looking up at the guild members with a strained grin. "This proves I have what it takes, doesn't it? Who could resist dear, deformed little Victoria?"
"Bugrit," said one of them. "Bugrit. I told 'em."
"I believe what Ron is trying to say," said the Duck Man, "is that while your brother is a classic Mumbler, the Beggars' Guild really has no place for a young lady of your... er... talents. Have you tried the Fools?"
- - -
Yes, I know they aren't members anymore, but it was funnier this way. At least in my head.
~Neshomeh -
Trying my hand at this, haha. by
on 2014-09-18 19:47:00 UTC
Reply
8/ Elemental Girls at Hogwarts
When 4 new students going by the names of; Summer Flame, Rosely Forest, Sky Thundercloud and Icey Tsunami enter Hogwarts as 2nd years. They have to defeat old Villains and deal with Love. Will their secret be found out and who will fall for who?
"So, what's the agenda?" Summer Flame asks over breakfast in the Great Hall.
"Love is being a whiny little child again, so we're going to have to deal with her," replies Rosely Forest, pressing a kiss to Sky Thundercloud's head as the other girl takes her place next to her at the Hufflepuff table. The four girls had decided to sit there together even though they were all sorted into different Houses based on their elemental-sounding names (someone's gotta be laughing about it, somewhere); after all, not many people paid too much attention to the Hufflepuff table.
"Okay, and Villains?" asks Summer.
"Still demanding their fee," reports Icey Tsunami as she heaps eggs onto her plate.
Sky shudders. "What a creep."
"What choice do we have? They've got information on us. If the Ministry finds out --" Rosely begins, but Sky squeezes her hand and shakes her head.
"Don't. We're going to find some way to make sure old Villains doesn't get that information to the Ministry."
Rosely briefly smiles at her girlfriend before turning back to the others. "Who's going to deal with Love then?"
"I'll do it," grumbles Summer. -
Heh, I thought about doing this one, too. by
on 2014-09-19 17:05:00 UTC
Reply
And had basically the same idea to make Villains and Love into characters.
("Rosely" and "Icey"; seriously, who thought those names were a good idea...?)
~Neshomeh, amused. -
It really bugs me too! by
on 2014-09-19 20:59:00 UTC
Reply
I mean, okay, Icey might have worked if was Icy, thought I would forever associate with the Winx Club villain of the same name.
Rosely though, that might work if it was in my language, but
in English it is just awkward. It would never work.
But well, who have said that Badfic( That has to be a bad fic!) writers have any sort of logic that is not Bad Logic, least of all in making up names? -
If you don't mind by
on 2014-09-19 23:39:00 UTC
Reply
what is your language?
-
It's Portuguese (nm) by
on 2014-09-20 19:31:00 UTC
Reply
-
Nice. ^-^ by
on 2014-09-19 12:27:00 UTC
Reply
Aggressive literalism based on typographical errors has always been the best way to do Fill the Plothole. And the implied plot here is perfect.
hS -
I really should've closed that italics tag. (nm) by
on 2014-09-18 19:48:00 UTC
Reply
-
And my own contribution: #3 by
on 2014-09-18 11:34:00 UTC
Reply
3/ The Daughter of Elrond
The Ring has been stolen and a daughter of Elrond is missing. Rated T for possible language.
"Celebrían?"
"Yes, my heart?"
"Would you care to help me solve a riddle?"
Celebrían laid aside her embroidery, folded her hands on her lap, and looked up at her husband. "Of a surety," she said. "Come, sit."
Elrond settled himself on the bench beside her, draping one arm across her shoulders. He leant back and gazed up at the ceiling, and Celebrían drew herself in against him.
"A certain... article of mine has gone missing," he said. "A thing of no little value, though few would mark it such."
Celebrían narrowed her eyes. "I presume, Lord of Imladris, that you do not refer to the keys to our wine cellar."
Elrond chuckled. "No, my love, they are safe with Erestor - though how 'safe' that truly is when Galion is visiting from Eryn Galen, I dare not contemplate. No, it is... rather a smaller thing than that." He swallowed, and added hesitantly, "Coloured blue."
Celebrían pulled away and turned to stare at him. "You have lost Vilya?" she exclaimed.
"Not lost," Elrond reassured her, squeezing her shoulder, "merely misplaced. I had removed it to change Lindir's dressings - and remind him yet again that he is not fit to return to the hunt, nor should he be so eager after being so wounded last time - and when I turned away..." He shrugged, letting the remainder go unsaid.
"We must organise the household," Celebrían declared, getting to her feet. "Each must be questioned in turn, and if none will reveal the Ring of Air's location, we shall search their-"
"You are most certainly your mother's daughter," Elrond interrupted, smiling, "but there is no need. My assistant in my labours was a certain dark-haired beauty of Tinúviel's line, but for reasons entirely unknown, she departed ere my task was complete."
Celebrían raised a delicate eyebrow, and her tone lightened to match his. "Did she, indeed? That is a mystery. Do you think she might be able to hear us now?"
Elrond tilted his head, listening, and caught a whisper of breath, the faintest of giggles. "Do you know," he said, "I rather suspect she can."
What? They never said which Ring. As for the language - well, it was possible, but fortunately Celebrían restrained herself.
hS -
D'awww. by
on 2014-09-19 17:11:00 UTC
Reply
I figured the daughter of Elrond would be Arwen, because, y'know, there aren't any others, but kid!Arwen making off with Daddy's pretty shiny thing is awesome. ^_^
~Neshomeh -
Absolutely brilliant and adorable. (nm) by
on 2014-09-19 16:56:00 UTC
Reply