Subject: A thought...
Author:
Posted on: 2018-06-04 08:18:00 UTC
When you brought up villains being portrayed as heroes, my mind immediately went to Loki. Characters of his type (not villains, per se, but incredibly adaptable trolls) would probably be amused to no end by a lot of badfic. If they were more or less in their right mind they would probably try to take advantage of the situation.
Not that I imagine Loki particularly would have many opportunities to do this, because he tends to be one of the most butchered characters I've seen in MCU fanfic. I think his opinion of his portrayals in fanfic would range from amusement to anger, depending on the particular portrayal.
Loki doesn't think of himself as a villain, and neither do a lot of fanfic writers. Fundamentally we see agreement, but the problem arises when you look at the way the fanwriters tend to defend him, which more often than not is portraying him as weak, or more victimized than he was in canon. I don't think Loki would appreciate that.
And I also think he wouldn't much like any fanfic that had him too far out of character. Fundamentally Loki and most other villains like who they are. Seeing someone twist their personality to the point most badfics go to would probably not make them happy.
Besides, I've seen a fair amount of goodfic that's managed to portray villains as good guys to at least some extent. If it can be done well, there's no need for them to approve of it being done badly.
TL;DR: Using Loki as an example, I think that it's unlikely that badfic interpretations of villains as good guys would please the villains much, since it usually involves some warping of character. Also I've seen that done well, so there's no real use to doing it badly.