Subject: Pretty much. Anakin was backed into a corner.
Author:
Posted on: 2019-01-14 20:14:00 UTC

Agreed, it's not that he wanted to fall to the dark side. He saw it as unavoidable if he were to save his love. He realized, perhaps, that the Jedi had been utterly blind when Palpatine revealed himself. He realized that he couldn't trust them anymore if they couldn't find a Sith lord right under their noses. And then he tried to rationalize everything, to stick to doctrine, by reporting his findings to Windu. And then he realized (with telepathic help from Sidious in the movie) that while he could be (relatively) certain of saving Amidala with the knowledge offered by Palpatine, according to the Chancellor himself at least, he feared that the Jedi would give him only condemnation and exile, because they'd been so stubborn on attachment beforehand.
See, if I were Anakin I would've fired up my lightsaber and lopped off Palpatine's head once he admitted he had lost the knowledge I so desperately needed. It seems a more logical solution than sticking with him when he admits he can't deliver on his offer. And then I would get the attention and validation from the council that I so desperately craved, by virtue of being the one to take down the Sith Lord. Hell, maybe I could use my confirmed status as the Chosen One to bring about reforms that would let me stay with my wife, but that would probably be wishful thinking. But with the immediate crisis over, who knows? Maybe the foundation of the Order could be revisited...
Of course, then the original trilogy would be reduced to an AU....

Reply Return to messages