Subject: Permission Granted!
Author:
Posted on: 2018-11-26 15:47:00 UTC

Not much to add to that, really. I know who you are, I've seen you write these characters in prompts and stuff, everything here is in good shape SPaG- and character- and PPC-wise, and that fic certainly sounds like it needs killing!

Single point of critique: In the second piece, I wouldn't have Kat actually invite the Sunflower's Witness in. I see that the SW is being pushy and you probably intended for Kat to just give in, but she "allows[s] the woman to enter" and they all settle down nicely around the table like they're going to hear her out. After that, the twins' prank on her seems mean-spirited. A couple easy ways you could fix it:

1. Kat says nothing, or maybe says something to put the SW off, but reluctantly gives way to the pushing.

2. If you want to keep the line of speech, have her say it after the SW barges past her, ironically.

Either way, no polite sit-down. If they don't want her there, they should act like it.

I spent a lot of text on that, but it's really only a couple of lines out of place in a piece that works just fine overall. Fix that, and the rest is good to go!

As are you. Sally forth, knight of Plort, and spork with a glad heart!

~Neshomeh

Reply Return to messages