Subject: doctorlit reviews Captain Marvel (MCU spoilers)
Author:
Posted on: 2019-04-23 04:37:00 UTC

Saw Captain Marvel with my brother yesterday. Captain Marvel is cool. Also, Captain Marvel is cool.

Spoilers follow for . . . let’s see. Captain America: The First Avenger, Captain Marvel, The Avengers, Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. season two, Guardians of the Galaxy and Avengers: Infinity War.

Starting off with the “Thank you, Stan” version of the opening Marvel logo: adorable, and funny, and sad. What an excellent way to lead off the first movie since his passing!

The mystery of Carol’s backstory is set up and presented so well in this film! I feel like the film starts out with just enough ambiguous information, through the nightmare sequence, to inform the audience that something is missing, without making us too suspicious of any particular party right away. The pieces of Carol’s backstory that are given to us are seeded in just the right amounts at the right frequency, that the final revelation of the truth, and the discovery that the Kree were the real bad guys all along, simultaneously feels surprising and satisfying, because there was definitely something off about Kree society up to that point. (And I’m only talking about in this film; I was wondering how they were going to present the Kree as good guys when we’ve already seen them as villains to various degrees in Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and Guardians of the Galaxy before this point. I think they did a decent job.)

I loved all the little details that showed how primitive Earth’s technology is compared to the Kree tech Carol: having to hook various parts together into a payphone to get it to make intergalactic calls, her utter difficulty with using a keyboard and mouse, and her bemusement that the parking lot security guard didn’t have immediate contact with higher levels of military authority. (Though that’s more a contrast with Kree culture than technology.)

It was fun seeing Coulson, Fury, the Tesseract and, yes, even Ronan again. I was glad they let Ronan’s actor use a more normal-sounding voice, rather than the comically over-the-top baritone from Guardians of the Galaxy. The CGI making Samuel Jackson look young again was astounding; it never actually looks like a computer trick at any point. It legitimately looks like they pulled Jurassic Park-era Jackson forward in time to play the role. Absolutely amazing! My brother and I couldn’t settle the question of whether Coulson’s actor was also digitally de-aged, but I personally think Clark Gregg still looks young enough that they just needed make-up for him. Maybe I’ll look that up quick: Ah, they actually did use computer effects on his face, as well.

Going back to the Tesseract, my brother and I both got a bit confused, because we were under the impression that the Tesseract had been recovered at the same time as Steve Rogers, just before The Avengers took place. But apparently, Howard Stark went searching for the wreckage of Steve’s plane, and was only able to recover the Tesseract at the time. I can’t remember if that was actually mentioned on screen anywhere or not. But another timeline problem that seems less easy to reconcile is how many people saw Carol blasting energy out of her wrists, or saw Skrull transforming their appearance. Pretty much all the weird sci-fi stuff that took place during World War II could have fairly easily been covered up by S.H.I.E.L.D. (most of the people who saw HYDRA’s laser weapons got incinerated by them, and only Steve himself saw Red Skull’s real face.) So it seemed like the general world populace only became aware of the sci-fi elements of their universe after The Incredible Hulk and Thor took place. But I don’t know how S.H.I.E.L.D. could have convinced all the people on that bus that what they saw was swamp gas, or whatever. Seems like it breaks the timeline.

I like that the Skrull turn out to be good guys in the end, not only because it’s unexpected, not only because it avoids an “always chaotic evil” culture, but also because it appears that they are not involved with Earth in any way after this film, which means the fan theory that anyone who died in Avengers: Infinity War was really just a Skrull is almost definitely wrong.

A couple of errors, courtesy of my brother, who is in college to become an airline pilot, and therefore Knows Planes. Some of the planes used in this film in the 1989-ish flashbacks were wrong for the time period, and also changed between cuts within the same scene. (I’m not going to bother naming specific model numbers, because I’ll get that wrong.) But he chocked this up to the limited time and access the film crew probably had to be using actual military bases for filming. Also, the reason Carol and Maria were acting as test pilots is because they were barred from serving as proper Air Force pilots due to being women. But the U.S. Air Force started allowing women pilots in 1976, so women being barred from flight in the late eighties is anachronistic.

—doctorlit, Marveling

“No, no. This spoiler’s taken.” “No, no. This spoiler’s taken.” “No, no. This spoiler’s taken.” “No, no. This spoiler’s taken.” “No, no. This spoiler’s taken.”

Reply Return to messages