Subject: Oh! A trailer at last!
Author:
Posted on: 2024-08-23 10:23:55 UTC

And a release date in December... I guess it is the official Middle-earth Movie Month. :D

Wikipedia is low-key bickering over whether it counts as anime, given that it's being made by an American studio, who've hired a Japanese studio (Sola) to do the animation. That's why the original voices aren't Japanese. But... given what's going on with Helm's daughter, it's certainly anime enough for me.

In terms of the plot, from the trailer it looks pretty faithful to the tale of Helm Hammerhand. It's also visually a prequel to the LotR movies - that's our Edoras and Hornburg, not some new version. The main difference I clocked are:

a) Mumakil. We knew from the announcement that they would be in there; goodness knows what Haradrim gigaphants are doing in Dunland.

b) Was that a Watcher fighting a Mumak???

and c) Hèra, the extremely anime daughter of Helm.

Hèra is a canon character; she's the unnamed daughter of Helm who sparks the whole story of the movie off. She is not noted (in the relevant three paragraphs of Appendix A) as being this... well, anime. She swordfights with wrist-veils! She wears multiple random belts! She has a Great White Eagle buddy! Her voice actress thinks she's written more like a Miyazaki/Ghibli character than a Tolkien one!

But... for all that it's written by Philippa Boyens with advice from Peter Jackson and Fran Walsh, I think they've actually put a decent amount of thought into Hèra. Her name is actual Old English, and Wikipedia specifically discusses how they named her. It also says she was based on Æthelflæd, Lady of the Mercians, who is a fantastic historical anomaly (a Saxon ruling queen who fought off the Vikings for seven years, and passed her realm to her daughter). So I'm cautiously optimistic that she might not be as jarring as the trailer wants her to look.

Oh! Also! Miranda Otto narrates in character as Eowyn, which is amazing, and also explains why Hèra stands out so much against the other characters. Because if Eowyn was going to have a favourite historical character, it would absolutely be a Shieldmaiden of Rohan.

hS

Reply Return to messages