Subject: re: “Of Scribbles and a Stu”
Author:
Posted on: 2025-01-09 12:18:53 UTC

(My reading time is rather inconsistent right now, but I’ll get to the second story when I’m able!)

I don’t know how long you’ve been setting this up, but I remember thinking during some of your more recent stories that Jiwon’s tail was bigger than I pictured in my head. I assumed I had just gotten a wrong impression of what the tail looked like, but now I see it actually has changed over time. Very sneaky! You wrote the change so subtly, I didn’t see it happening! And even when Jiwon brought up the size change at the beginning, I somehow didn’t expect the explanation that was coming by the end, even though it feels plainly obvious now. I’ve heard of nine-tailed fox legends before, but it didn’t occur to me that Jiwon could turn into one, especially not all at once like this! It makes for an interesting metaphor for Jiwon’s personal growth, because even though he may not appear to have changed much since the beginning of the spin-off, he absolutely has become more confident and less anxious over time. Perhaps getting all nine tails at once is a sign that he’s developed as far as he can without radically changing who he is? Whatever it means, I think it’s a very clever idea!

I understood, from the Doylist viewpoint, that this mission was based on one of your old stories, but in Watsonian mode, I was puzzled by what Intelligence meant by labeling the story an “old shame” in-universe. Jiwon and Charlie are pretty clearly not author insert-style characters, as they themselves discuss. Aaaand . . . I admit, I didn’t understand the relevance of their console saying, “don’t take me as well.” I thought it was worried about getting stolen or something. But the idea that the console has been this spin-off’s self insert all along, and was scared to confront its old shame (and has been writing the mission reports the whole time!) . . . OrangeFox, that is genius, and extremely funny. I very much enjoyed reading that twist at the end!

I figured out pretty early that the “chessboard” the agents were seeing in place of the Words had to be comic panels, based on the description you were giving inside the fic. Honestly, I had great fun reading the descriptions here; you did an excellent job of describing a child’s drawings the way they would look and feel as a solid environment. Honestly, it was kind of endearing, and early on, I found myself rooting for you not to be too harsh on your younger self. The comic is cute! It’s a little kid having fun and being creative! So I really like the ending. Oh, and I love that the agents’ disguises matched the aesthetic of the comic. Making Jiwon into another fox with magical fire is perfect, but I especially loved that Charlie just became a stick figure with cat features on the head. It’s just so cute and funny, and really feels like it matches Charlie’s vibe. All that said, I think this is the single most justified usage of a CAD screaming and melting after trying to give a reading of a character. I’ve read so many such scenes by now, I often feel the trope is overplayed, but in this story, it made me laugh out loud!

Nitpicker doctorlit wants to battle! Nitpicker doctorlit sent out Continuity Errors!
. . . being defended against the Haunter, his Gengar goons . . .
I believe these were Gastlys a couple scenes before?

The agents watched the Ferroseed hop . . .
This is a Ferrothorn everywhere else in the story. Then again, in the actual comic, it looks more like a Ferroseed to me, so . . . I don’t know, it’s your story, lol!

The opposing Continuity Errors fainted! Nitpicker doctorlit sent out Missing Words!
Another fight was ongoing, just in time to watch the lead stickman
Either the sentence trailed off, or the end punctuation is missing.

With that, they leaned back against ramp and watched . . .
the ramp

Nitpicker doctorlit withdrew Missing Words! Nitpicker doctorlit sent out Excess Letters!
The Pokémon slid across the floor of the gym less like static jpegs.

"Why'd you ask if you're not gonna do it anyway?"
I think I’m reading this right, going to be embarrassed if I misunderstood the conversation!

He wasn’t there in the last one, was he?” T

The Destiny Bond took Excess Letters down with it! Nitpicker doctorlit sent out Thefollowingpairsofparagraphsaremissingthedoublespacebetweenthemeon!

“Still no Words.”
“That’s what that ‘right’ implied, yes.”

“. . . Well, what’s next, then?”
competitors, said the fic . . .

“Somewhat, yes.”
“Nice.”

And I don’t really know what Pokémon joke to make for the last two, so:
An A, T, E, and R follow suit,
“followed”

Charlie clapped their stIck-hands rapidly.
Snuck a little of yourself into that “stick,” didn’t you?

—doctorlit awards OrangeFox the CHARACTERARCBADGE! DOSAT technology up to level 30 might obey you, sometimes!

Reply Return to messages