Subject: My LotR favorites
Author:
Posted on: 2012-07-11 16:18:00 UTC

My overall favorite thing about Lord of the Rings and Tolkien in general is that he writes beautifully. Yeah, he goes on a bit sometimes, but when a master linguist wants to talk, I don't mind listening. I admit I struggled when I was younger and didn't really understand these things, but my appreciation for his writing has only deepened as I've grown. I fell in love all over again when I learned in college that alliterative verse was a thing and finally understood what was going on with the Rohirric songs. Genius.

Y'know what, let's start with:

Favorite Song

... Actually not one of the Rohirric ones. Sorry! My favorite is actually the one that Sam sings in Minas Morgul when he's got the Ring and the orcs are convinced he's a big scary elf warrior, but they've all panicked and basically killed each other off, and now he's lost, and he's trying to find and rescue Frodo, and the only way to do that is to keep making noise because the last guard standing thinks Sam is Frodo (because who else could it be, everyone else is dead or fled), and will lead the way:

In western lands beneath the Sun
   the flowers may rise in Spring,
the trees may bud, the waters run,
  the merry finches sing.
Or there maybe 'tis cloudless night
  and swaying beeches bear
the Elven-stars as jewels white
  amid their branching hair.

Though here at journey's end I lie
  in darkness buried deep,
beyond all towers strong and high,
  beyond all mountains steep,
above all shadows rides the Sun
  and Stars forever dwell:
I will not say the Day is done,
  nor bid the Stars farewell.

Truthfully some of this probably comes from the tune used in the BBC radio play version, but it's just so sweet and so hopeful, this simple little song standing up to one of the darkest, scariest places in the world and fact that the most important person in the world is in serious danger of his life... It brings tears to my eyes, and I'm not just saying that.

Pretty much everything Rohirric is a close second, though. For instance:

Out of dark, out of doubt, to the day's rising
I came, singing in the sun, sword unsheathing
To hope's end I rode, and to heart's breaking
Now for wrath! Now for ruin! And a red nightfall...

Stirring! (See the alliteration, guys? See how it tells you where the emphasis goes? Isn't it cool? {= D )

Favorite Character

Y'know, it changes, because it's pretty much a three-way tie between Aragorn, Sam, and Faramir. Two of things that most pissed me off about the Peter Jackson movies were things that screwed around with the latter two for no good reason, and Aragorn's treatment was pretty annoying at times, too. He didn't need angst, thanks very much, he already had enough on his plate to be going on with—but no. Gotta have self-doubt and angst, 'cause we have to get the lowest common teenage denominator to relate. -_-*

Okay, so maybe Aragorn is my favorite character. To be fair, there is a kernel of self-doubting and concern about his worthiness there, but part of the reason I like him so much is that he's capable of putting that aside to do what needs to be done, because it needs to be done and he's the only person around who can do it. This is a man who has the strength of character to love a woman for decades without being able to be with her, and to go on fighting the good fight because not only is it right, not only is he really the only man for the job, but also it is the only way he will ever have any hope of being with Arwen. And then he still has to be King.

And what's more, he never bitches about it, unlike some characters from other series I could name who are stuck in positions of life-or-death, world-shaking importance. I think he mentions like once to the hobbits that his is a pretty lonely life, and then it's back to business. Aragorn is a guy who's old enough to know that moaning and complaining doesn't improve things, so he doesn't waste his energy on it. He focuses on getting the job done. And he's good at his job.

Oh, and did I mention patience? Compassion? Fairness? Hands that wield both life and death?

I wanted to be Aragorn's sidekick as a kid. I still wouldn't mind. I could toughen up, I swear. I'd work really hard. Just teach me, please.

Favorite Scene

I think I agree with hS here: when the Rohirrim turn up at the very last minute to break the siege of Minas Tirith, it's just one of the greatest things ever (see above totally cool alliterative verse—a lot of it happens in this scene). The arrival of the ships a bit later is slightly diminished because they're following such a great act—although by then things are even more desperate, because oh god how are they still losing after all the badassery we just witnessed!? So that's a pretty amazing moment, too.

Favorite Person to Hate

The Mouth of Sauron. Man, I hate that guy. He shows up all of maybe twice, if that, but he's just such an arrogant, lying scumbucket. He is a lying liar who lies, and it's a good thing he's got so much mouth, so there's more to punch. Jerk.

But, to end on a good note:

Favorite Location

Middle-earth is full of really cool settings, some beautiful, some awe-inspiring, some just plain scary, and I want to see all of them (well, maybe not the really scary ones), but I think I'd start with the Great River, because I love rivers and water in general. I wanna visit the Falls of Rauros, and the Rapids of Sarn Gebir, and go see the Argonath, and climb up Amon Lhaw and Amon Hen and maybe even Tol Brandir if it looked like I could get away with it without falling off and dying. The view from any of those places would be intense. Maybe I'd pick my next destination from there.

~Neshomeh

Reply Return to messages