Subject: My LotR(/Silm) favourites
Author:
Posted on: 2012-07-09 10:43:00 UTC
(I didn't need my thunder anyway. No problems ;))
What is Middle-earth?
In short, the Saga of the Jewels and the Rings - roughly seven thousand years of fully integrated and cohesive mythology, plus an unknown length of time before that going back to The Beginning. It's not just a story - it's a world, where most of the stories and poems are written by people within the stories (hence LotR is almost entirely written from a Hobbitty PoV - and where it isn't, it's from a people-telling-things-to-Hobbits PoV) - it's a huge toy, really, with some awesome stories about real(istic) people.
Why do I like it?
Basically that. :P Partly because there's just so much there - if you've read LotR, The Hobbit and Silm, there's still Unfinished Tales and Children of Hurin to go - and after that there's 12 volumes of the Histories, and then Letters (which contains some things not otherwise mentioned), and The Road Goes Ever On (Tolkien-approved tunes for the songs!), and the Atlas, and just everything.
And then there's the unofficial things like Ardalambion, where you can find out everything about an aspect of the world (in this case, the languages - did I mention he made fully-working languages?), and it's just fun. And the story and writing style are captivating - the arrival of the Rohirrim at Minas Tirith is still my favourite piece of writing ever.
Oh, and I think there were a couple of films at some point.
My Favourites
(Since this was where I was originally going with the idea...)
Favourite Character?
Finrod Felagund, hands down. The Elvenking of Nargothrond who ruled over half of Beleriand (back in the First Age, the Elder Days some 7000 years before the War of the Ring) and (which is more) made the other half get along with each other by sheer force of personality - but still found time to debate the nature of mortality with a human woman and expound his vision of What Happens After. One of the few Kings of the Eldar to actually listen to the Valar (he was guided by Ulmo to set up one of the longest-lasting Elven strongholds, which only fell because of Turin - but more on him later), who was named Wisdom by the mortals (not to mention his mother)... and who gave up everything, realm, friends, freedom and ultimately his life, to help the mortal Beren achieve the Quest of the Silmaril. Awesome fellow.
Favourite Character You've Heard Of?
Well that's far more difficult. Probably Galadriel - who incidentally is Finrod's younger sister, and a lot like him. Ludicrously powerful, but able and willing to step into the background and not overshadow Celeborn (except in the films) - this despite the fact that she was one of the most enthusiastic about the whole 'Go to Middle-earth and get stuff to rule' thing. She's the one who resisted Feanor, Sauron and the Ring - and the summons of the Valar to go home, for more than six thousand years.
Favourite Scene?
I said this already: the coming of the Rohirrim to Minas Tirith in RotK. This scene. It has a fantastic emotional flow - and the actual writing is amazing.
Favourite Person To Hate?
Turin. Oh dear Valar I dislike that man. How does one man manage to cause the destruction of two ancient realms (and then his dad made the first chink in the armour of the third)? And, y'know, how does he manage to be such an idiot about it? Hint: if they're bringing a message from the only Vala who wants anything to do with you (Ulmo), your response should not be 'But I like my bridge too much to tear it down'.
The release of The Children of Hurin is a cause of both disappointment and hope. On the one hand, it's Turin and I really don't like him. On the other hand, if Christopher can cobble together one novel from the Silm legends, who's to say he won't pull out the Lay of Leithian or Fall of Gondolin some day? Well, as I say, I live in hope.
(I think I'll stop here)
hS