Subject: Also thoughts
Author:
Posted on: 2012-04-18 22:05:00 UTC

I didn't really take that into consideration for a few reasons.

For one, Holmes as a character is only plausible where there is sense and logic. He works completely off of his reasoning skills. That is, there are things that add up that can be reasoned from in a logical manner, and that's where he gains those things you're concerned about as a character in any incarnation. Logic and things building up to a reasonable conclusion isn't something one can do in a badfic.

Badfic, more often than not, has these giant leaps where there is no sense or reasoning behind what is done in them, which would basically break that.

Second, his partner also has to be taken into account. When agents are too similar, or one is more dominant than the other, there is less room for potential humor, because the clashes and differences are generally what bring dynamism into the spin-off. AnnaBee's sample shows us that both aren't the sort to give in or let the other steamroll them, and Mundar's personality is chaotic enough- and frustrating enough for Vernet- that it throws Vernet off fairly quickly as indicated in that sample. Future parts will likely show continued blocking, ignoring, doing things without regards for Vernet, and so on.

With those things in mind, I didn't really see it as much of an issue, given where the character is being used and with who as an intended partner.

Reply Return to messages