Subject: Very nice.
Author:
Posted on: 2011-09-25 16:37:00 UTC

It's always nice to see some of these underutilized PPC divisions focused upon or otherwise made reference to. Not only does it allow for new and unconventional stories, it serves to further build the PPC universe.

Much of what I wanted to address concrit-wise has already been addressed by Phobos and Vixenmage. There are a couple of unaddressed points that I feel should be touched upon, though. There are points in the dialogue where it isn't really made clear who is talking at any one point. I had to reread several sections just because I did not know who was saying what.

There is also the matter of the story's frequent use of one sentence paragraphs. I would not mind it so much were the sentences in question important ideas that really needed to be emphasized in their own stand alone section, but this does not seem to be the case. 'Gerry huffed.' probably does not need to be in its own paragraph.

Finally, I really liked the way you explained what an Enderman was in the text. It was succinct and contained all the information someone who does not play Minecraft needs to know about this creature. Well done in that regard.

I apologize if any part of my criticism seemed overly harsh or accusatory. This is a nice little story with interesting characters and I look forward to seeing them again. Kudos!

Reply Return to messages