Subject: Assumption Three occurs.
Author:
Posted on: 2010-08-23 19:55:00 UTC
Everyone wins.
-
Character tournament: Who Would Win? by
on 2010-08-22 23:22:00 UTC
Reply
So, PitViper and I ended up having a discussion about which of various canonical characters could defeat others in a fight. I think we ought to hold a tourney of sorts; name two characters, and everyone who knows those characters discusses which one would win if they fought.
For example: Cluny the Scourge, of the book Redwall, versus the mortal self of Drip Tiberius Rat in the webcomic Jack. Discuss. -
Cluny, maybe? (nm) by
on 2010-08-24 00:55:00 UTC
Reply
-
Nita Callahan vs. Hermione Granger? by
on 2010-08-23 18:56:00 UTC
Reply
Assuming:
--They actually have a reason to fight
--They both have time to prepare, to even out the higher preparation time required for spellcasting for Nita, and to let Hermione use her 1337 Research Skillz
-They don't immediately forget about fighting and start comparing their respective systems of magic
Neither one is allowed to call on allies.
Who wins? -
Assumption Three occurs. by
on 2010-08-23 19:55:00 UTC
Reply
Everyone wins.
-
Oh, yes, this. by
on 2010-08-23 08:24:00 UTC
Reply
I think I already said my money's on Cluny if he goes against mortal Drip, as Drip's a serial rapist who, according to what I've seen of canon, only kills women he attacks, who are presumably helpless. Cluny has battle experience, and as was mentioned before, a frickin poison tail barb. Now Demon-Drip, on the other hand, would have a much better chance, but I'd still say Cluny, simply because he's better equipped and Drip doesn't have much in the way of power. His only advantage would therefore be size.
I propose my own, now. Joel Calley (with Miranda's help) from the webcomic Concession versus Damien from El Goonish Shive. -
Ooh, tough one. by
on 2010-08-26 01:15:00 UTC
Reply
On a physical level, Damien's more than a match for Joel; Joel's a regular mortal, and Damien's got the burning and super-healing. On the other hand, if Miranda gets into his head in time ... probably Joel and Miranda, then.
'Nother one: Joel versus the Woodland Critters of South Park? -
I like these things. by
on 2010-08-23 07:44:00 UTC
Reply
But as I have no real knowledge of either of your combatants, I will pose a fight of my own.
100 Red Shirts (Star Trek) vs. 100 Stormtroopers (Star Wars) -
Stormtroopers win. by
on 2010-08-23 16:28:00 UTC
Reply
Clone/Stormtroopers never hit main characters, but they manage to kill unnamed bit characters all the time. The Red Shirts would go down pretty fast.
-
The world would divide itself by zero (nm) by
on 2010-08-23 08:16:00 UTC
Reply
-
Actually... by
on 2010-08-24 05:20:00 UTC
Reply
...when I came up with idea I turned to Nesh and said, "I think I may have just divided by zero."
-
I vote Cluny. by
on 2010-08-23 04:31:00 UTC
Reply
I've never read the Redwall series, but I'm pretty sure Cluny the Scourge is some kind of warrior. Drip was just a crazy murderer in life, who controlled his victims with threats. That wouldn't work on Cluny, and Cluny has the advantage of combat training that mortal!Drip couldn't match.
-
Well... by
on 2010-08-23 04:08:00 UTC
Reply
I don't know anything about Drip, so I'd have to say Cluny by default.
I will bring up that his habit of wearing a poisonous spike on his tail would probably end up being a lethal surprise to his opponents. Is there a restriction on weapons or armor? -
I think in this case there'd have to be a no-weapon rule. by
on 2010-08-23 11:00:00 UTC
Reply
Drip's only weapon was occasional use of a gun, which would kind of be cheating. To make it properly fair they'd both have to have their tails tied round their waists, as the no-weapon rule would rule out Cluny's tail-whip and if he tied it up he'd be unbalanced ...
I kind of hope it would be Cluny that won. The mental images if Drip won are too disturbing. -
I'd vote for... by
on 2010-08-23 17:31:00 UTC
Reply
each to have their standard or most common weapon selection.
-
I don't know if Drip really used weapons much. by
on 2010-08-23 22:27:00 UTC
Reply
I think he used a knife at one point and a gun on another occasion, but he didn't really have a trademark weapon.