I'm definitely in the camp of people who want to introduce her to a star. Or... hmm. Don't the Silmarils burn? Maybe you could introduce her to Varda, who could borrow Earendil's Silmaril for a moment. 'Cause, you know, Sue would be too dumb to let go of it and be burned. And it wouldn't be quick, either.

Which would be satisfying, no?

Drop her in the middle of the Kinslaying. I don't know off the top of my head if she'd look like one of the Sea Elves (or even if that's the right term for them), but there's still a good chance she'd be shot or burned or trampled or drowned or all of the above.

~Neshomeh, who can't think of much worse a fate for any elf-kin.

I skimmed through the fic, and it looks totally insipid. I'm thinking coat her in honey or something and leave her in the Midgewater Marshes.

~Neshomeh

…and leave her to Melkor in the War of the Jewels?

I think the real Elbereth might delight in paying her a visit. Wonder if Middle-earthian stars are also huge fiery balls of fire and gas...