Subject: [Applause]
Author:
Posted on: 2014-03-14 20:41:00 UTC

The reason, sadly, is that both those quotes come from unfinished works that weren't published until the influence of LotR had become entrenched.

With ironclads, airships, thunder-missiles, and Alcarondas, the black-and-gold flagship, that is an even more epic fleet than I'd imagined. (So why does Alcarondas have sails and masts? Either Numenor never invented steam power, or it was a deliberate thumbing of the nose to the Eldar - 'Look, we have unimaginable technological power, and we can build sailing ships bigger and better than yours'.)

And how did the invasion end? The Valar dropped a mountain range on them. Or so we're told, by...

... by...

... well, by no-one, actually. The only people who could possibly have brought that information to Middle-earth are the Istari and Glorfindel. And I doubt they'd admit to anything other than 'yeah, the Valar crushed them like worms, so don't try it'.

So... yeah, you're right. It needs to be done. But can it be done in writing? I don't know - and since I can't draw, that may prevent me from doing anything with it.

Maybe it should be a game?

(One tragic point: there's no suggestion that their airships were metal. Though their sailing ships were.)

hS

Reply Return to messages