You actually managed to read through both those train wreck?

*claps*

I applaud you, good sir. I've snarked both those fics at one point (Subject 23 was a PPC mission and Parallel Realities was my first snarking with the Library of the Damned), and I know how both these fics were.

For me, though, I'd have to say that Subject 23 would probably win the fight. Actually, I'd say that I want Subject 23 to win, really. Thing is, Subject 23 is a psychopath and he's whiny and the things he does to Miranda's character are completely horrible, but at least he doesn't take over the whole galaxy at the end the way Stupard does.

And I think Subject 23 probably would win anyway, so there's that. He's basically just an X-Men character transplanted into the Mass Effect universe, so that gives him an edge against Stupard. On top of that, Subject 23's abilities allow him to keep some distance with Stupard, so that would probably help a lot as well.