Subject: Re: Looking at the Killed Badfic page...
Author:
Posted on: 2013-11-24 02:19:00 UTC
S'alright.
-
Dear God... by
on 2013-11-22 04:47:00 UTC
Reply
Would anyone like to kill the fic that adds in something called Sylvari, apparently from a continuum called Guild Wars, forces Treebeard out of character, has a Sue
called Ceres who is speshul, in-jokes that make no sense, etc. And this is from the first two chapters. It's called Wild Growth and it's on the Pit. -
If it brings in /any/ aspect of another continuity by
on 2013-11-22 15:23:00 UTC
Reply
... Then I'd say it counts as a crossover, wouldn't you?
The author's note makes me think that the kid should know better. For one thing, they can spell. -
Exactly. by
on 2013-11-22 21:05:00 UTC
Reply
The author thinks that it shouldn't be marked as a crossover, despite adding a species, names, and characters from Guild Wars.
What is this sort of crossover called? Full co-habitation? I think it could be that. -
Depends whether it's deliberate. by
on 2013-11-22 15:42:00 UTC
Reply
And specific, for that matter. If I have a character refer to an off-screen train named Thomas, that doesn't mean it's a crossover with Thomas the Tank Engine.
On a side note, saying someone 'should know better' is another way of saying they don't; that means it's bordering on a personal attack of sorts, which obviously we don't do. ;) It can be a pain at times, but that's how it goes.
hS -
Re: Depends whether it's deliberate. by
on 2013-11-22 22:30:00 UTC
Reply
It's one thing if the series references something in another fandom, but this one seems to have adopted a chunk of worldbuilding.
Ah, sorry. What I suppose should be said, in the more politically correct way, is that the suethor seems a bit different from our run-of-the-mill suefic writer: they have a good grasp of spelling and grammar, and possibly a beta reader. - Courtesy Link by on 2013-11-22 11:22:00 UTC Reply
-
Re: Courtesy Link by
on 2013-11-22 21:57:00 UTC
Reply
Precisely. Has it already been murdered?
And it's demon miss, my friend. :) -
Looking at the Killed Badfic page... by
on 2013-11-23 15:34:00 UTC
Reply
It seems that no, it was not. Also, I stand corrected.
-
Re: Looking at the Killed Badfic page... by
on 2013-11-24 02:19:00 UTC
Reply
S'alright.
-
Link? by
on 2013-11-22 04:50:00 UTC
Reply
I have limited knowledge of Guild Wars, I'm just gonna go check if a Sylvari is what I think it is.
-
Embarassed by
on 2013-11-22 04:58:00 UTC
Reply
Er...how do you link something on this website?
-
just copy and paste the address by
on 2013-11-22 05:25:00 UTC
Reply
like this
http://ppc.wikia.com/wiki/PPC_Wiki -
Alternatively... by
on 2013-11-22 12:18:00 UTC
Reply
Use HTML link markup. See here for the know-how.