Subject: Hrm. I'm not sure it worked.
Author:
Posted on: 2013-08-20 10:30:00 UTC
There are two ways to play with an idea, such as the standard UFO setup: to play it straight, or to deconstruct it. I don't think you really hit either of them:
-If you're playing it straight, you're relying on people realising what you're using. Assuming you don't want to just tell them (and you don't), that means you need to give them enough information to figure it out. You may have based the descriptions off specific 'sightings', but unless you show the story only to people who've heard of those examples, it won't really twig.
--As an aside to this, your 'Greys' line, with this explanation, bothers me, because it was the Xrvillian's idea in the first place! That would be like me finishing this post with "Oh no! platypus might get concrit!" - when I'm the one giving it.
-To deconstruct the standard story, you don't necessarily need to make it clear what you're playing with - but you need to take the pieces and rationalise them. I think that's what you tried to do (Why would aliens abduct humans? Becuase they want to scan their brains for this reason), but I don't think it worked. I guess the reason I think that is that apart from the single idea, you pretty much did play it straight.
To achieve the effect you were going for, I think you'd be best to set your story a little later. Don't show us 'Haha, now we shall steal the humans' brains!' - show us 'Well, we've scanned these humans' brains - now what?', or, 'Oh, hey, welcome to the Galactic Community. We might have a few things to apologise to you for...'.
I guess what I'm suggesting is, play with it. Humans have weird minds, so the aliens want our brain scans - great, that can work. What else can you play with? How can you take things from the generic UFOs and subvert them? ('White? Our ships aren't white - oh, I see, your eyes don't read ultraviolet...' 'Right, we've got one of the apes - goodness, I didn't know they were so large and quadripedal...' 'Okay, real human this time. Erm, where exactly are their brains...?') Just playing it straight as an attempt to highlight 'how ridiculous the standard little green men are' simply leads to people assuming your story is ridiculous. It's a similar approach to 'I shall write a deliberately terrible story to show how bad badfic is!'. Well, yes - but you're showing by example, not by analysis.
hS
PS: The word 'smile' denotes happiness or pleasure. It's not a value-less facial expression. ~hS