Subject: Nonono, Trekkie gushing is good!
Author:
Posted on: 2013-02-28 21:02:00 UTC

The 2009 movie is actually the very first ST I ever saw (yup. Newbie. It's why I then went back and started at the very beginning). I can see where you're coming from with the sleek and modern bit, and also with Dr. McCoy's catchphrase.

Actually, in TNG, one of the first episodes I saw...well, I was thinking along much the same lines as you were with the 2009 film. I was going, 'this isn't my Star Trek. I want my TOS characters back. The Enterprise is too fancy' (as you can tell, it hadn't come close to winning me over yet). Then, a rather aged Dr. McCoy came onscreen, and had a conversation with Data, which was, in a word, AWESOME. And it tied everything together, and made it better, and made me laugh. It also made me a little more willing to give TNG a chance, I think. (Since then, I've become rather fonder of the TNG characters, but originally...they were just too unfamiliar, and in different uniforms and a fancy starship to boot).

As it is, I think the TOS titles will always be the ones to 'welcome me in', as we're calling it. Mainly because I have such fond memories of the series? Who knows. Maybe just because I first heard them nearly four years ago.)

~DF

Reply Return to messages