Subject: I don't see how that can count.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-04-18 22:07:00 UTC

If it doesn't have the same plot, the characters are changed if they're there at all, and it obviously has a different setting... it's a different canon. Whatever you think of the books, the movie can hardly be compared that way any more than you can compare any other pair of different canons.

Especially since the book's whole message got flipped. The book was about becoming a hero the hard way. In the movie, Hiccup was the only one with a dragon, and it was a Special Uncanon Dragon.

Basically, it's movie-form fanfic. With the parameters you're applying to the question, I could just as easily say "Frozen" and be in the same ballpark of adaptation-vs-separate canon.

Reply Return to messages