Subject: Or indeed the other way round.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-01-13 11:07:00 UTC

They did claim to have been Here all along, after all.

If they were created with Arda, then when Yavanna awakened the Ents it would've been by force-evolving the Vashta Nerada to the 'make a tree sentient' stage. Huorns are then explained by Ents sharing their VN with normal trees, and taking back non-evolved VN in trade - the trees become more Entish, and the Ents become more treeish, exactly as Tolkien described.

And of course we know that the 'Entish' trees still exist today - there's one on the grounds at Hogwarts, isn't there? (In fact, isn't that a willow? Do... do we know for sure that it's not Old Man Willow? I'm sure we could jig the map to place the Old Forest in Scotland if we tried...)

(...)

(... someone please confirm that there exists Old Man Willow/Whomping Willow slash)

hS

Reply Return to messages