Subject: Well, thatÂ’s a recurring discussion.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-12-26 12:08:00 UTC

Should everything be spelled out, or is it sufficient to mention that the Reader recognizes the Riddle, although her not recognizing the Riddle wouldn’t change the plot? It obviously depends on which kind of stories you like.

Since it is there, it must be significant in some way. Since it apparently isn’t plot relevant, it is either a red herring to distract us from the surprise solution that will be presented later, or it is a hint that the Aviator’s way of solving the Riddle is something she has in common with the Reader, but doesn’t share with the Librarian.

  1. They both are Time Ladies; the Librarian is a guy.
  2. They may both possess excellent language skills that have never been hinted at.
  3. They share experiences in a universe the Librarian doesn’t know.
  4. The Riddle of the Osirians may be well known on World One’s Earth (obviously under another name), and Arin may have told little Saa about it.
  5. ...
For some readers, it’s fun to jog our brains, trying to find the most plausible solution.

Since I came up with Nr. 4, I can’t decide between it and Nr. 3. Does somebody know a children’s book whit a pun-based riddle where the solution is a mouse?

HG

Reply Return to messages