An intelectual discussion on cretaive mediums... by
World-Jumper
on 2015-10-05 22:51:00 UTC
Reply
...and the impact they have on storytelling.
As this is a community founded on around the consumption of media, and the preservation of their thematic presentation within derivative works, I thought an exercise in debate over how the presentation and use of creative medium affects greater storytelling. So please, have a warm cup of tea at your side, ready your monocle, and let us chat.
Also, I will drop the pretentious act.
So, I was listening to the most recent episode of the Co-Optional Podcast (a fantastic gaming podcast that I highly recommend, even if just for entertainment value. Just know, they do use adult language) when they started discussing the difference between interactive mediums and more traditional storytelling, which then further branched off into a talk over how storytelling in general is affected by the means in which they are presented, such as those that say listening to an audio book is not truly experiencing the story as the author intended, and thus, inferior. I would ask that everybody listen to the appropriate segment of the podcast HERE. It is what they say the conversation will be based on. (By all means, listen to the rest of the podcast if you wish. Just a reminder, it is rated Mature for a reason. The clip is not, the podcast is.)
Feel free to discuss how creative mediums affect storytelling in any way you wish. I do have guiding questions, if you need a springboard for your thoughts, but feel free to simply state your thoughts on the topic at large.
The guiding questions:
Do you like audiobooks? Why or why not? Is it because of a personal preference, or are there intrinsic flaws in either medium?
What are your opinions on adaptations? Do they, on average, help or hinder the original work? Does it matter?
Why would a creator potentially chose to write a book over a graphic novel, or film a movie over shoot a television show? What intrinsic differences are there that can help or hinder a storyteller convey their message?
I look forward to reading your Intellectual Responses.