Subject: My opinions.
Author:
Posted on: 2015-10-06 05:02:00 UTC

I feel i cannot yet give any sort of reasonable opinion about audio books
because I have exposed myself to the medium precisely once. All I can say is that I like that particular audio book and that I am not disinclined to try another one.

I think that it is pretty much inevitable that something will be lost in translation, so to speak, when it comes to adaptations, especially when it is case of any longer medium being adapted to film and even especially when comes to any sort of interactive media being adapted to a non-interactive one.

That doesn't mean that they have to be necessarily bad though, just severely diferrent experiences. I can even account for at least one case where the movie adaptation was a major improviment on the book.

With the choice of media, I think it mostly comes down to how you want to convey that message. Books and Visual Novels generally allow you to peer more closely and deeper into the psyche of at least one of characters involved because of the necessary presence of narration. That doesn't mean that you can't relate meaningfully to characters in other media, which the contrary, just that relationship will present itself under a different form. Every medium posesses traits that makes its experience radically differently from any other and without which the experience probably wouldn't be able to work in the same way.

Take Visual Novels for example. One of my favorites stories out there is Kana Little Sister. Would that experience have worked just as well without any sort of interactivity, without all the different choices, routes
and endings? Probably not. But would that experience also have worked without the intimate relationship created by the narration provided by protagonist, without the extensive amount of text involved, the CGI backgrounds, or even the wonderful background music? I am also willingly to wager that it probably wouldn't have.

Reply Return to messages