Subject: Oooooh
Author:
Posted on: 2015-10-06 03:16:00 UTC
I love audiobooks because they're super easy to multitask with- drawing, commuting, whatever- though a definite drawback is time. It's generally a little faster to read the book yourself than listen to an audiobook. For me, audiobooks are generally more relaxing, especially if they have different voices for different characters. :P I don't believe intrinsic flaws exist in either medium; both have pros and cons.
Don't have any particular opinions in adaptation! It really does vary from situation to situation. Good adaptations probably ultimately add to the interest of the work as a whole. Bad adaptations do the opposite. Of course, this then breaks into the semantics of what constitutes "good" and what constitutes "bad", which can obviously vary from person to person, so.
As for book vs. graphic novel, some stories are just meant to be in one or the other. If you've ever read Neil Gaiman's "Sandman" comics (and if you haven't, I highly recommend them, they are so good), you might get what I mean. Could the series have been conveyed well through text alone? Probably. Would it have been effective in its message, themes, or general appeal? In my opinion, probably not!
Books with deliberately ambiguous characters or settings also benefit more from written rather than illustrated, as it leaves a certain amount of interpretation up to the reader.
And movies vs. television series? Probably more "there is way too much important footage to fit this into a single or even two movies, guess we're making a miniseries" :P miniseries can probably fit in more suspense and cliffhangers, and also have the obvious added bonus of nigh unlimited time for plot lines.