Subject: Harry Potter question (Deathly Hallows)
Author:
Posted on: 2016-07-26 09:11:00 UTC

So I've just read, for the very first time, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.

[Pause for screaming]

Actually, I've just read for the very first time everything from Goblet of Fire onwards, but that's-

[More screaming]

-BUT THAT'S not relevant. It's DH that I have a question about.

Is there any consensus as to who or what the 'wretched creature' hanging out in Ghostly King's Cross was? Dumbledore refuses to say (except that it's pointless to waste pity on or try to help). I wondered if it was Voldemort, but a) he's still alive (though maybe unconscious), and b) Dumbledore is clear that the Horcrux-fragments are 'destroyed', not just dead.

So then I wondered if it could be Grindelwald? They do talk about him a fair bit, he has only recently died, and he and Dumbledore have A History, so it would explain why Albus was hanging out with him.

Or is it someone or something else? I can't really think of anything that would fit (the spirit of the first owner of the Elder Wand?), but...

hS

PS: Oh, but this version of Deathly Hallows has the best ending. The much-debated epilogue ends at the bottom of the front side of the very last page. I turn it over, and see, printed large on the inside back cover itself, JKR standing by her desk with a smirk on her face that seems to say, "Yep, I just did that. Nope, you can't argue it away. Yep, it's canon now."

I tried to find a copy of the picture online, but honestly, she always smirks like that. Look at all the pictures!

hS (again)

Reply Return to messages