Subject: Answers?
Author:
Posted on: 2016-07-26 12:41:00 UTC

Why didn't Voldemort realise Harry wasn't dead?

Maybe this baby-like creature is even more helpless than a newborn, unable to see, hear and comprehend what’s going on? Voldemort may not even remember the experience.

Concerning Dumbledore, I guess he is not really there. It’s all in Harry’s head (but based on reality), and Harry tries to do what he is used to do near the end of every book except HBP. But since Dumbledore is only imagined, he can’t actually tell Harry anything Harry can’t figure out on his own. Harry may still get things wrong and change his mind later.

  • Most obviously, Harry is not yet aware that Dumbledore hadn’t planned to make Snape the new Master of the Elder Wand; he realizes only later that dying undefeated so that nobody can become the wands new master would be the best plan and is probably what Dumbledore intended.
  • Harry is not ready to admit that the golden spell that saved him from Voldemort on the flight from 4 PD was Voldemort’s soul piece using Voldemort’s magic imbued in Harry’s wand to protect itself. (That’s only my theory, afaik never confirmed by JKR.)
  • His view of Dumbledore tainted by Rita Skeeter’s poison, Harry may believe that Dumbledore wouldn’t try to redeem Voldemort, but being Harry, he has to do it anyway.

And since it’s all in Harry’s head, Voldemort’s experience in his head may actually have been different.

HG

Reply Return to messages