Subject: So when do we get Part One then? ^_~
Author:
Posted on: 2018-05-08 20:32:00 UTC

I jest, I jest (mostly).

I really like the spell in the new section (I've already commented on the first part, right?). The physical mirroring of the name to match the mirroring of... huh, she never gets a name, does she? Ixiwiz - is excellent, and feels very Duane-ish. I also like the idea hinted at that the House of Mirrors isn't just Ixiwiz's fears writ large - it's a malevolent entity (possibly even an entire parallel dimension?) that feeds off people's fears. That fact turns this from a story about Ixiwiz gaining self-confidence (which, under most circumstances, wouldn't in itself justify the Powers' offering wizardry to her) into one about her taking down a major problem that could practically have been designed to trap her.

There's a principle in the books that 'all is done for each' - that while you're out solving problems with your Art, the problem solving ends up helping you, too. This is very much at play here, at least in the subtext.

One thing I will highlight is the fact that in the /first/ half, you pulled all the subtext out and named it. It started off unclear, but eventually the Mirror was flat out saying 'I'm your Ordeal'. The transition to all the themes being unstated, only seen by implication, is mildly jarring; I'm actually wondering if it migh be deliberate? The shift happens at the moment Ixiwiz starts completely ignoring the Mirror, so it could be thematic.

Another thing I like is that you've done something none of the rest of us did, but all the main-series canon Ordeals do: you've made Ixiwiz an active participant in getting to the Hall of Mirrors. Where Jacob, Lise, Julia and Marisa just found themselves in the relevant locations, and Siobhan was dragged there by a parrot, Ixiwiz actively teleported there. Sure, it was accidental - but Nita and Kit didn't intend to go where they did, either.

The one question I really want to see answered - the one that makes me actually ask for Part One - is: why Ixiwiz? It's clear why the Hall of Mirrors needed to be shattered, but what made Ixiwiz uniquely suited to the task? In the other completed stories, we have geekery, rocketry, and cyber...y, all making the kids in question The Right Person to take on their various threats, but here it almost seems the opposite: like Ixiwiz was a /bad/ choice, because she was likely to fall prey to it.

What's running through my head as an explanation (I can't help it, I headcanon everything) is that maybe that's the point. The Hall of Mirrors is obviously old and powerful - if I'm right, it's an entire universe of the Lone Power's domaim - and it must have learnt caution. A confident wizard who would blow it up with fire would never be able to find it. But someone who could be her own bait - who was exactly the sort of person it wanted to feed on, and a wizard to boot, so the Lone One would be delighted to take her out - but who was at heart strong enough to overcome it... that's someone who the Powers could extend the Oath to, and let her solve Their problem and find her own solution along the way.

hS

Reply Return to messages