Subject: How would that work, anyway?
Author:
Posted on: 2019-07-22 09:40:00 UTC

Not the speciality quiz, that's just bog-standard Quizilla work. But the Oath generator?

You have to come up with something that will give both (variations on) the classic Oath, but also the full version of Darryl's from the intro to Alone:

Life:
  more than just being alive (and worth the pain)
but hurts:
  fix it
grows:
  keep it growing
wants to stop:
  remind check / don’t hurt
be sure!
  One’s watching: get it right!
later it all works out,
  honest
meantime, make it work now
  (because now is all you ever get:
  now is)

(I'm not positive why this is described as an excerpt, since it starts and ends with the same points as the classic version, but there you have it.)

Are there other canonical Oaths? Skimming through On Ordeal, I don't think Roshaun or Mamvish get one, and Ronan uses the SoYouWiz version... still though, we have to assume that there's variety out there.

I think what you'd have to do is split it up into parts. You have an initial dedication (In Life's Name...) and a final invocation (Where All Our Sundered Times Are One). Darryl's Oath mentions pain, growth, various other concepts; so you have variants on each of those for the generator to plug in.

You also have a structure. Nita's Oath is prose; Darryl's is... whatever it is. But you have to have rhyming poetry as an option, too, as well as (presumably) other options. For each of those, you need at least 3 variants for each part, which the generator can choose from.

I guess it would also want to re-order them? Some people are going to want 'guard growth, ease pain' to come right at the top; others are going to need the 'in Live's service alone' to take priority.

And all of this comes from a quiz... which hopefully is more actually inquisitive than the Potter wand quiz.

(Kaitlyn has said, and I agree, that it's quite baffling that fan oaths aren't more of a thing. It seems like the very first thing you'd come up with, right? I guess the original is so good that we all think it's too hard to beat... though Tumblr throws out a few options. Kaitlyn's favourite is The Activist's Recension.)

hS

Reply Return to messages