Subject: Here's another Tolkien one: Girl falls into Middle-earth and becomes the Tenth Walker
Author:
Posted on: 2020-04-12 20:39:54 UTC
JunoMagic/satismagic's Lothiriel manages to do "Girl falls into Middle-earth and becomes the Tenth Walker" in a canon respectful manner.
It does use the "Westron is English" convention, but other than that, I can't recall any canon issues and in light of how good the story is, I can ignore it. It even manages to place her as the Tenth Walker in a logical manner - Gandalf suggests sending nine and one walkers, to quote directly from the story, "A counterpart to the nine riders foul and black, and one on top, a sign of hidden strength we may yet possess."
There are also some formatting issues in earlier chapters, but they aren't so bad as to make it unreadable.