Subject: Here's another Tolkien one: Girl falls into Middle-earth and becomes the Tenth Walker
Author:
Posted on: 2020-04-12 20:39:54 UTC

JunoMagic/satismagic's Lothiriel manages to do "Girl falls into Middle-earth and becomes the Tenth Walker" in a canon respectful manner.

It does use the "Westron is English" convention, but other than that, I can't recall any canon issues and in light of how good the story is, I can ignore it. It even manages to place her as the Tenth Walker in a logical manner - Gandalf suggests sending nine and one walkers, to quote directly from the story, "A counterpart to the nine riders foul and black, and one on top, a sign of hidden strength we may yet possess."

There are also some formatting issues in earlier chapters, but they aren't so bad as to make it unreadable.

Reply Return to messages