Subject: Well, that's why we kill them.
Author:
Posted on: 2022-03-18 14:29:18 UTC

Taking the Council as the example, the PPC has to stay on top of things. We have to keep killing the badfics, because if we let them stick around, poor Elrond will indeed be swamped with Suvians. Once they're dead, they never happened, so the problem is solved!

... yeah, it's not an idea that holds together overly well. I seem to recall Suedom takes the route that the canon is looping - that Lord of the Rings runs from the Long-Expected Party (or maybe the departure from Bag-End) to the sailing of the White Ship, then resets and repeats. Or maybe each location loops, so Rivendell is an endless cycle of Councils of Elrond, with nothing actually existing outside that. If a Suvian injects herself into the Council, then she's part of the loop now - she'll repeat until an outside agency (the PPC) comes in and removes her. If we don't do so before another Suvian tries to enter the same scene, they'll meet each other and we'll all be in trouble.

It's a theory. It explains the observed data about as well as the many-universes theory, especially if you add some caveat that a PPC mission extends the loop until the agents leave (somehow? Maybe in a literal, fourth-wall breaking "because the mission is a story too" way). I don't particularly like it, because it makes the canons into puppets just acting out their creators' words endlessly - but it also means the PPC are fighting against a concrete threat wherein a Suvian is literally affecting the main canon, and has to be stopped before she loops and everyone notices. The current 'slight destabilising effect' is a bit less urgent.

Since Suedom was never finished, we could even argue that the unseen, unexplained Bridge in that story is where things changed - before that, the canons were just endlessly repeating loops, but the Bridge made them into something new - worlds of their own.

hS

Reply Return to messages