Subject: I have finished reading it, and the premise was weird, but it's not bad.
Author:
Posted on: 2023-01-13 17:57:07 UTC
I agree with the non-missionable verdict.
-
I haven't even read much of the fic, but the premise is weird, uncanonical and impossible. by
on 2023-01-12 23:17:53 UTC
Edited
Badfic report
Reply
I have only read the first two chapters, but it's already looking iffy. Ramandu falls in love with a sea serpent named Myanweth. I don't think Narnian sea serpents are sentient like that, and why would one fall in love with a Star? I will admit that I don't know the explanation of the origins of Ramandu's daughter, but this seems implausible. Also, this fic seems to be turning her into a Sue.
(Edit: I bumped the Beta Request button instead of the Badfic Report button. Oops.)
-
Hey, Book: by
on 2023-01-16 13:24:15 UTC
Reply
How’s that MST of Laiacalasse’s Tale (that was it, right?) going?
—Ls
-
It's not going at all, unfortuntely. I have been obscenely busy all through Christmas and New Year. by
on 2023-01-21 01:31:55 UTC
Reply
So far, it looks like the chaos will not abate very soon. My problem is that I get inspired and start a project, but if it isn't a one-shot I tend to run out of steam.
-
Oh. Too bad. by
on 2023-01-21 17:14:35 UTC
Reply
Hey, do you want to talk via Discord? I'm Linstar#4919
--Ls
-
I have finished reading it, and the premise was weird, but it's not bad. by
on 2023-01-13 17:57:07 UTC
Reply
I agree with the non-missionable verdict.
-
I mean, how's the execution? by
on 2023-01-13 04:13:06 UTC
Reply
Maybe it's just me kinda relaxing on fic opinions over the years, but if it's done well it's done well, non-canon premise or not. (Heck, one of my favorite fics out there is Harry is a Dragon, and That's Okay, and that fic stretches canon quite a bit. Very solid work, if a rather long.) I actually like the writing style choice in this one, and to be honest... I'm not really seeing what makes this character particularly Sueish, especially with how bad they can get out there. Had a quick skim and she seems to just be chilling, and even if I missed something she could probably be a lot worse. I agree with Lin - it just doesn't feel very much like mission material.
-OrangeFox
-
Could be worse. by
on 2023-01-13 00:21:35 UTC
Reply
While the sea serpent bit is just bizarre, the fic’s structurally and stylistically pretty well-written.
I dunno if it’s missionable.
—Ls
- Since I'm on a Narniafic kick, have this one. I like it. by on 2023-01-12 23:46:08 UTC Reply
- I'll be confounded. I do not know what to make of this other one here. by on 2023-01-12 23:31:25 UTC Reply
-
What on Earth?!? by
on 2023-01-13 00:19:42 UTC
Edited
Reply
Why are Rilian and (Norse trickster god whose name starts with L) in love? Just WHY?
—Ls